Walt Whitman Poem Commentaries

“There is then creative reading as well as creartive writing. When the mind is braced by labor and invention, the page of whatever book we read becomes luminous with manifold allusion. Every sentence is doubly significant, and the sense of our author is as broad as the world.  . . . First we eat, then we beget; first we read, then we write”

––Ralph Waldo Emerson, The American Scholar

Project Timeline

  • Wednesday October 14 First draft of commentary #1
  • Friday October 30 Whitman commentary #2 and revised version of commentary #1
  • Monday November 2 Final Version of Whitman commentaries and commentary reflection uploaded to Writing Portfolio

Commentary Project

  1. Choose a Poem from the 1891–92 edition of Leaves of Grass. This link to the Whitman Archive takes you to the page with the individual poems and clusters. (Published Writings > U.S. Editions of Leaves of Grass > Leaves of Grass (1891–92).
  2. Search for and use textual, contextual, and critical information about the poem
  3. Use the information you find in a 500-word descriptive commentary
  4. “Write something. Make it good. Make it better.”
  5. Upload your commentary to the Google folder

The commentaries are descriptive. You will not be writing to advance an interpretive claim. Rather, the work is to discover, describe and elaborate on the poem. It is important that you choose poems that interest you, or that challenge you. And it is imperative that you also do a comprehensive survey of the secondary criticism to find out exactly what others have said about the poem.

Each commentary will demonstrate an awareness of the formal and thematic concerns of the poem as well as the ways the poem has been read by other readers. You are responsible for reading and quoting from, when appropriate, readers who have published commentary on your poem.

Each entry will include

  • the poem (single spaced)
  • a succinct overview of the poem (or section or segment of a long poem) and a focused commentary of no more than 500 words
  • a bibliography and further reading section that directs readers to the extant commentary on the poem

The format for and content of each entry will follow the sequence below:

1st paragraph: Text and Context Historical and factual information

textual information

  1. texts have histories (manuscripts, versions, editions) that may be relevant
  2. texts first appeared where (date and location) and then in book form
  3. poetics: poem (verse) structure: lyric, narrative, dramatic

contextual information

  1. biographical (only if relevant to poem)
  2. social/cultural (only if relevant to poem)
  3. when the poem occurred in the arc of the poets career

Can end in transitional summary sentence to continue the commentary

2nd paragraph: Summary of the poem Descriptive account of form and content

  1. relevant details of poem structure (octave/sestet, narrative book-length poem, etc.)
  2. relation of poem to other poems or texts or contexts
  3. relevant summary of poetic features (language, imagery)
  4. relevant lines, phrases, words quoted as evidence

3rd paragraph: Critical reception of poem Tradition of commentary and conversation about the poem

  1. How was the poem received by contemporaries?
  2. How has the poem been read by readers since its publication?
  3. Are there critical debates or different ways of reading the poem?
  4. How does the poem fit into a literary tradition?

4th paragraph: Conclusion Informed comment about the significance and/or interest of the poem

Most students of literature and culture I have worked with in the past have been surprised at the challenges (and pleasures) of descriptive writing. Most everyone has found these pieces of writing especially rewarding, too, as they are written for a general audience and not merely for the teacher of the course.

Research portals and archives

Mason Library Home Page

Whitman Books and essays in the Mason Library 
Center for Research and Writing
Archives and Special Collections

Library Databases

Walt Whitman Archive

The Poetry Foundation
The Academy of American Poets
Wikipedia

3. Examples from a Book of Commentaries (written by students at Keene State College)

The entries published in American Poetry and Poetics will be useful as models. And we will discuss descriptive writing in class. Examples: Walt Whitman, The World Below the Brine and Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, The Wreck of the Hesperus