It is difficult
to get the news from poems
yet men die miserably every day
for lack
of what is found there.
––William Carlos Williams, from “Asphodel that Greeny Flower,” Journey to Love (1955)
Context I: Ideas and Intellectual Traditions
The context of our course is poetry and poetics; and in writing about poems and poets and the discourse of poetics you are part of an ongoing conversation that I have been pulling you into all semester. You have been reading (and writing about) poems and you have been reading prose statements by poets, critics, and theorists In an introductory college course, of course, you are not going to see all of the dimensions of this fascinating conversation.
But you can be aware of it; and you can use this awareness as you begin to write your way into a conversation about language, poetic form, and ideas. Read over the “Teacher Talks” I have written this semester; review the materials now archived on the “Workshops” page; and reread the poems we have read together: in reviewing the materials you will gain more confidence in what you have learned and you will likely see exciting connections across these primary and secondary materials.
It is also the case that materials we might gather under the category “poetry and poetics” is part of a more capacious field of human activity (literature and culture) that involves other kinds of experiences and thinking, whether psychological, social, political, moral, or philosophical. For instance, if I am writing a poem that engages with society I would eventually become aware of the intellectual context in which I am writing: for instance, I would find my way to the ideas of C. Wright Mills, Erving Goffman, and Pierre Bourdieu, three field-defining (and field-expanding) sociologists who shaped how we think about society, societal norms and institutions, and social change. If I am writing about the natural world, my writing would likely be informed by the intellectual context that shaped how we think in a more ecological way about the human and more-than-human world, a context that includes the ideas and empirical research of people such as Eugene Odum, James Lovelock, Rachel Carson, E. O. Wilson, Sylvia Earle, Vandana Shiva, and Robin Wall Kimmerer.
Context II: The Stories of our Lives
This course is organized around the premise that poems offer a vocabulary for knowing something about the world around us. This is the world that our experiences (and the humanities and science) teach us that we can never fully know. But to know (and to be) who we are is to know within the story we use to organize our lives.
Here is the neurologist and clinician Oliver Sacks explaining the constitutive place of story in our lives in a notable passage from his book The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat (1985).
We have, each of us, a life-story, an inner narrative — whose continuity, whose sense, is our lives. It might be said that each of us constructs and lives, a “narrative,” and that this narrative is us, our identities. If we wish to know about a man, we ask “what is his story — his real, inmost story?” — for each of us is a biography, a story. Each of us is a singular narrative, which is constructed, continually, unconsciously, by, through, and in us — through our perceptions, our feelings, our thoughts, our actions; and, not least, our discourse, our spoken narrations. Biologically, physiologically, we are not so different from each other; historically, as narratives — we are each of us unique.
One can read this alongside a passage from George Saunders’ book A Swim in a Pond in the Rain: In Which Four Russians Give a Master Class on Writing, Reading, and Life (2021), in which he argues not only that our singular inner narratives are constructed but they are also determinative. Our stories are evidence of how when make our inner lives we become subject to “a delusional gulf. . .between things as we think they are and things as they actually are:
The instant we wake the story begins: “Here I am. In my bed. Hard worker, good dad, decent husband, a guy who always tries his best. Jeez, my back hurts. Probably from the stupid gym.” And just like that, with our thoughts, the world gets made.
Or, anyway, a world gets made.
This world-making via thinking is natural, sane, Darwinian: we do it to survive. Is there harm in it? Well, yes, because we think in the same way that we hear or see: within a narrow, survival-enhancing range. We don’t see or hear all that might be seen or heard but only that which is helpful for us to see and hear. Our thoughts are similarly restricted and have a similarly narrow purpose: to help the thinker thrive.
All of this limited thinking has an unfortunate by-product: ego. Who is trying to survive? “I” am. The mind takes a vast unitary wholeness (the universe), selects one tiny segment of it (me), and starts narrating from that point of view. Just like that, that entity (George!) becomes real, and he is (surprise, surprise) located at the exact center of the universe, and everything is happening in his movie, so to speak; it is all, somehow, both for and about him. In this way, moral judgment arises: what is good for George is… good. What is bad for him is bad. (The bear is neither good nor bad until, looking hungry, it starts walking toward George.)
So, in every instant, a delusional gulf gets created between things as we think they are and things as they actually are. Off we go, mistaking the world we’ve made with our thoughts for the real world. Evil and dysfunction (or at least obnoxiousness) occur in proportion to how solidly a person believes that his projections are correct and energetically acts upon them.
Here is the thing: Saunder’s distinction between “a world” and “the world” is unsettling. It places demands on us we might otherwise ignore. It confronts us with how little we actually know about ourselves and the world. At the same time, it suggests that we can imagine through learning and growing and changing the ways we think and act in the world.
Poetry and Knowing
This space between worlds is of great interest to poets. Consider this poem by Denise Levertov, “Sojourns in a Parallel World,” from her 1996 collection Sands from the Well:
We live our lives of human passions,
cruelties, dreams, concepts,
crimes and the exercise of virtue
in and beside a world devoid
of our preoccupations, free
from apprehension—though affected,
certainly, by our actions. A world
parallel to our own though overlapping.
We call it “Nature”; only reluctantly
admitting ourselves to be “Nature” too.
Whenever we lose track of our own obsessions,
our self-concerns, because we drift for a minute,
an hour even, of pure (almost pure)
response to that insouciant life:
cloud, bird, fox, the flow of light, the dancing
pilgrimage of water, vast stillness
of spellbound ephemerae on a lit windowpane,
animal voices, mineral hum, wind
conversing with rain, ocean with rock, stuttering
of fire to coal—then something tethered
in us, hobbled like a donkey on its patch
of gnawed grass and thistles, breaks free.
No one discovers
just where we’ve been, when we’re caught up again
into our own sphere (where we must
return, indeed, to evolve our destinies)
—but we have changed, a little.
There are things we know, and there are things we don’t know. There is a world and there is the world beyond the world we have made. This is the condition of our lives. The poet Theodore Roethke, in his unforgettable poem The Waking, offers another instance of this interest in thinking and knowing. “We think by feeling. What is there to know?” In this case, what is offered is an assertion and a question, an untethering or breaking free that might lead us from where we are (or where we think we are) to someplace new.
As early as the first week of our class we were talking about feeling and thinking and knowing. You may remember, for instance, that I shared lines from Mary Oliver’s book-length poem The Leaf and the Cloud:
The pickerel
swims up from the pond from its roses of slow decay, and
looks at me
astonished.
What is it I need to know?
The gypsy moths, still caterpillars,
wrench themselves from the milky threads of birth
and set out on the long journey
in the shining tree.
What is it I don’t know that I need to know?
In these lines the speaker, reflecting on a “face to face” encounter with a pickerel, asks “What is it I need to know?” The speaker then describes the unfolding process of Lymantria dispar (the Gypsy Moth), which evolves through four distinct developmental stages––egg, larva, papa and adult (the moth). Did you know that during the larval stage of the life cycle of Lymantria, the female passes through six caterpillar instars, the male six?
Here Oliver enacts a process that leads from paying attention to asking questions. In the poem, the observation and description lead the speaker to a question about knowing. “What is it I don’t know that I need to know?” The questions that arise when we engage with ourselves and the world, the poem suggests, are about knowing: Who am I? Where am I? What am I doing here? What is going on? These are personal questions, about ourselves; but they are also philosophical questions, that have to do with understanding and making meaning.
Here is a recent poem by Patrick Rosal, Prayer for When I’m Lost. Note well the following lines,
prayer: give me a language for grief, jubilation, the gamut
of danger in waves. Let me name it aloud: Give this trouble
a shape.
In their way of knowing, or in Patrick Rosal’s words, “giving trouble a shape,” poems unsettle the stories we live by. Not unlike other forms of art, a poem can offer us a vocabulary for the things we experience, and name within ourselves (say, grief). You might say they explore the less accessible dimensions of our inner lives. Let us remember the journey in Adrienne Rich’s Diving into the Wreck, the encounter of the narrator with
the thing I came for:
the wreck and not the story of the wreck
the thing itself and not the myth
This kind of seeking requires us to move beyond ourselves and into the process of becoming. For the poet Mary Oliver, this movement becomes possible when we make use of the two gifts we are given in the universe: “the ability to love and the ability to ask questions” (48). To love and to ask questions, she reminds us, expand and extend us. “Let me be who I am, and then some” (10), is how she pleads her case in the first essay of her collection Winter Hours, for “life is no narrow business” (12).