This post is focused on preparing for a class reading of Walt Whitman’s prose work Democratic Vistas (1871): enacting the time-honored and utterly audacious activity of reading a book together.
On Starting with the Text
On the one hand, I asked you to start with text so that you refrain from seeking an account of another person’s reading to stand in for your own. This method is the (democratic) method of Whitman’s call for “complete” readers. As he says near what he calls the “apex” of Democratic Vistas, as readers, each of us, and together, must “construct indeed the poem, argument, history, metaphysical essay—the text furnishing the hints, the clue, the start or frame-work.”
In this remarkable passage, Whitman challenges a commonplace assumption about books. “Not the book needs so much to be the complete thing,” he says, “but the reader of the book does.” And he goes further, calling for a collective of readers: “That were to make a nation of supple and athletic minds, well-train’d, intuitive, used to depend on themselves, and not on a few coteries of writers” (133–34; all page references will be to the printed edition we are using in your class). I have quoted from his text to call our attention to his argument about the collective of literate persons, again, with “supple and athletic minds, well-train’d, intuitive, used to depend on themselves.”
In an essay I published a few years ago, Close Reading at the End of Time, I made a comparable argument for this idea of reading together. I write that we would do well to envision
the literary work of close reading as more than an event of the text and the reader but rather a more complex attending to the event of reading as situating the reader—in a community, that is, beyond the self. Or as Matthew Crawford argues in The World Beyond Your Head, as individuals, “we find ourselves situated in a world that is not of our making and this ‘situatedness’ is fundamental to what a human being is.” (26)
When we “start with the text,” on the other hand, of course, we are starting where we are: embedded in our history of experience with language, reading, and boundlessly prepared with a bundle of historical and social expectations that, when challenged, leave us entangled in the fact of the matter at hand: ourselves. But in “starting with the text” we are not starting with David Bromwich’s (excellent) introduction to the book On Democracy: Walt Whitman. Rather we will begin on page 33 in our editions, under the title in boldface text Democratic Vistas, with the first words of the essay: “AS THE GREATEST LESSONS OF NATURE through the universe are perhaps lessons of variety and freedom, the same present the greatest lessons also in New World politics and progress.”
On Starting with Words about Words
When we choose not to start with a text (words) we most often begin with someone’s else’s reading of the text (words about words). Let’s say I open a web browser (say Chrome) on a search engine (say Google) and do a title search for what I am reading. I receive an index of web pages. An algorithm has organized what arrives in your search window based on data, including data about you and your habits––location, search history, and so on. (Caveat emptor, or “let the buyer beware”: your search engine is neither neutral nor disinterested portals to information you might be looking for; rather, they make money from advertising things.)
When I typed into my browser “Democratic Vistas” it took 0.74 seconds for me to receive about 1,230 results. The first link is an encyclopedia entry on the essay, “Democratic Vistas [1871],” by Arthur Wrobel, a pre-print electronic copy of Walt Whitman: An Encyclopedia, ed. Donald D. Cummings and J.R. LeMaster (New York: Garland Publishing, 1998), at the by now familiar! Walt Whitman Archive. Wrobel was a member of the English department faculty, at the University of Kentucky, Lexington. (Below this first entry, I scan the 11 citations in the bibliography that follow. The list includes an essay by my dear friend James Perrin Warren, “Reconstructing Language in Democratic Vistas” in the book Walt Whitman: The Centennial Essays. Jim happens to be a retired professor who taught at Washington and Lee University.)
But before this first hyperlink there appears an “AI Overview.” This calls (or pulls?) my attention to other places. One of them is a short (4:19 ) YouTube “Summary and Analysis of ‘Democratic Vistas’” on a channel by Stanley St. Rose. Why wonder, I thought, so I looked for a brief bio so that I knew who was sharing the summary and analysis (Lessons 1, think about the author and their authority and the “container” of the information, in this case YouTube). I found it in the channel profile description. “Jesus Christ is Lord!!! From Christ and the Bible to everyday life, on this channel, I like to talk about all things. So, if you would like to join me please leave a like, comment, and subscribe.” Turns out the guy likes to post summary and analysis, and there is a timeline and a transcript.
The other source (“above the fold,” as people say about the lead stories on the top of a printed newspaper) is a book-length commentary on Whitman’s “Democratic Vistas” at the web site of the Cato Institute (container, check) an American Libertarian think tank, founded in 1977, based on Washington D.C. The commentary is edited with six brief introductions––inserted into Whitman’s text by Anthony Comegna (author, check), the Assistant Editor for Intellectual History at Libertarianism.org. Comegna received an M.A. (2012) and Ph.D. (2016) in history from the University of Pittsburgh, where he specialized in early American, intellectual, and Atlantic history. For the Cato Institute and Libertarianism.org, he produces regular historical content, columns, and scripts for the “Classics of Liberty” podcast.
In his penultimate headnote, “Mother of the True Revolutions,” Comegna concludes, “Whitman’s Democratic Vistas was both prophetic and naïve” (72). And in the final note, “The Whole Orb, Comegna’s framing is stated clearly and directly, as he pauses with his readers to “reflect on the great poet’s dual role as a restless, progressive, almost futurist libertarian and yet a harbinger of the sort of romantic democratic nationalism that has characterized American life—and American imperialism—ever since. Whitman’s life was absorbed with the twin pursuits of producing original American national art and decades of political activism for radical libertarian causes.” Then, at the end of the book, printed on one of the final leaves, is the following statement:
Libertarianism.org Liberty. It’s a simple idea and the linchpin of a complex system of values and practices: justice, prosperity, responsibility, toleration, cooperation, and peace. Many people believe that liberty is the core political value of modern civilization itself, the one that gives substance and form to all the other values of social life. They’re called libertarians. Libertarianism.org is the Cato Institute’s treasury of resources about the theory and history of liberty. The book you’re holding is a small part of what Libertarianism.org has to offer. In addition to hosting classic texts by historical libertarian figures and original articles from modern-day thinkers, Libertarianism.org publishes podcasts, videos, online introductory courses, and books on a variety of topics within the libertarian tradition.
If I were doing a workshop on “media and information literacy,” we would be talking about authority and reliability of information. We would talk about how information is constructed (for example, by experience and expertise) and contextual (It really does matter, for a number of reasons, who is writing or saying something, their purpose for writing or saying, and the “container” of the information, whether a YouTube channel or a Washington-based think tank).
On Working in the Walt Whitman Archive (1)
We have been starting to work in the Walt Whitman Archive. Last week, we did an in-class workshop, in which I asked you to
-
- Choose a line (or lines) from one of the poems we have read today: I Celebrate Myself (13–56) and Come Closer to Me (57–64) in Leaves of Grass (1855)
- Copy and paste (or transcribe line(s) into a document
- Search for interesting/relevant information about the lines (form, production, reception) in the Walt Whitman Archive
- Document what you find, and include links to the page(s) you discover in a document
- Upload your working document to Google Folder Walt Whitman Archive Workshop #1 Fall 2026
One of the inquiries began with lines chosen from “Come Closer to Me” (that would be incorporated into the poem “The Sleepers”) :
“If you remember your foolish and outlawed deeds, do you think I cannot remember
my foolish and outlawed deeds?
If you carouse at the table I say I will carouse at the opposite side of the
table;
If you meet some stranger in the street and love him or her, do I not often meet
strangers in the street and love them?” (1855 58)
After circulating in class, and talking with most of you, I typed these lines from Whitman’s poem into my browser and was presented with the following information in the “AI Overview”:
I’m really not sure what is meant here by “famous.” And what I “learned” has no reliable provenance. Who says this? Where? If I were to inquire further, say, using the Whitman Archive, I would encounter a number of problems. While the lines (called “the quote”) are supposed to be in the 1885 edition, it turns out that the poem “The Sleepers” did not appear in the 1855 edition. Here is what a scholar (Burton Hatlen) says:
The poem that has become known as “The Sleepers” was first published as the fourth of the twelve untitled poems in the 1855 edition of Leaves of Grass. In the 1856 edition it became “Night Poem,” and in the 1860 and 1867 editions it is titled “Sleep-Chasings.” It acquired its final title in the 1871 edition. (The Table of Contents of the 1855 edition in an editorial apparatus added for help with navigating the content of the volume. For the Complete Edition has only “Leaves of Grass” diving the lines into discrete sections. There are no titles.)
The next step is to look for the lines. It turns out that a quick search will show that the lines actually appear in the second poem in the 1855 sequence, what in the editorial scheme of adding titles is “Come Closer to Me.” (A finding such as this is one of the reasons our exercise asked us to work in the Walt Whitman Archive.) If you trace the lines you will follow them into Poem of The Daily Work of The Workmen and Workwomen of These States (1856) that would later become part of the first numbered section of A Song for Occupations in the final edition of Leaves of Grass (1891–92).
Now back to our in-class workshop. What was of interest to the readers of these lines was Whitman’s use of “I” and “you.” It turns out that these terms (and their relations) are at the center of Whitman’s poetics; and they have been a preoccupation of Whitman’s readers and in the secondary commentary on his work. I suggested looking at another poem and we turned to a particular moment I suggested in the poem Crossing Brooklyn Ferry in the 1891–1892 edition of Leaves of Grass:
It avails not, neither time or place—distance avails
not,
I am with you, you men and women of a generation,
or ever so many generations hence,
I project myself—also I return—I am with you, and
know how it is.
Just as you feel when you look on the river and sky,
so I felt,
Just as any of you is one of a living crowd, I was one
of a crowd,
Just as you are refreshed by the gladness of the river,
and the bright flow, I was refreshed,
If you are interested in Whitman’s relationship with his reader, these lines are fascinating. If you are interested in finding out more about the “I” and the “you” and their relations, there are many place to go in the Archive.
In our Google document, though the lines from Whitman are followed by a link to a “web log” or blog. The link is to an April 2020 post on My French Quest: Adventures in Literature, French Culture and Language Acquisition. The post is a reflection on the poem “Whoever You Are Holding Me Now in Hand.” The personal mediation by a reader on the “I” and the “you” and their relations, with sentences that make statements about the matter at hand, such as “Whitman sees his readers as an active audience,” is evidence of an engaged and relatively informed reader sharing her interesting insights on the open web.
As you can see, we are back to another case study in the lesson that “authority and reliability are constructed (for example, by experience and expertise) and contextual (it really does matter who is writing or saying something and their purpose for writing or saying).” Farah and Olivia (our students in this story of poking and prying with a purpose) offer a concise summary of the author’s point:
- In this article the author is explaining how Whitman sees his audience as an audience. Whitman is the speaker, we are the audience. He wants us to feel connected to him that the distance between him and his audience isn’t that far.
The author of the blog post (“Robyn”) is a widely-read writer sharing descriptive and interpretive adventures with authors and texts. It is self-published, by an author with linguistic expertise, that would be useful for readers and, perhaps, in certain kinds of academic and literary projects.
On Working in the Walt Whitman Archive (2)
But back to the search results and the 1,230 results. Below the fold—tucked under the featured AI-generated material, in the right window box, is a link to the brief Wikipedia entry (overview) article Democratic Vistas. It lists the publication year as 1871, and the author, Walt Whitman. So far so good. But then it lists the genre, “Poetry.” (Democratic Vistas is a work of prose.)
What follows is a link to an original facsimile edition, edited by the Whitman scholar Ed Folsom, published by the University of Iowa Press. Then a Pdf of the book at the Internet Archive, from the nineteenth century, with an inscription by the author, a lovely edition indeed.
Now back to where we started, and where I want us to play. The Walt Whitman Archive. A quick scan of the History of the Project will give you a sense of the integrity of the Archive and there is a fine description of its purpose:
Whitman scholarship is thriving: he remains one of the most discussed figures in American literary and cultural studies. Despite his prominence it has been difficult to study the evolving nature of his work because several of the important editions of Leaves of Grass have been inaccessible unless you happen to teach at a research library with a strong rare book room.
Curiously, scholarship has largely ignored Whitman’s poetry manuscripts in part because of related problems of access. The manuscripts are scattered widely at over sixty different libraries. Our work on the manuscripts, once completed, ought to significantly alter the conversation about the nature of Whitman’s creative process, his compositional practices, and the meaning of some of his key poems.
Students have also, as a result, been less informed about Whitman and his many contributions to literary and cultural histories around the world. But the Archive changes the game and makes it possible for any reader and student or scholar, with access to the internet, to engage with Whitman’s poetry in new and exciting ways.
As far as Democratic Vistas, well, there are places to go. For instance,
Complete Prose Works > Democratic Vistas (pp. 203–58) takes you to the primary text––which, of course, you can annotate. You can read the text on the scanned manuscript pages, if you wish. And you can search:
Index of Works > Democratic Vistas to find all known versions of the work, organized by the section in which they appear on the Archive (20 primary documents and 5 secondary commentaries).
Or
Literary Manuscripts > Integrated Catalog of Walt Whitman’s Literary Manuscripts> Democratic Vistas (20 items)
Pay careful attention to the intertextual pathways above. They are ways to navigate the archive that you will be using during the next few weeks as you begin writing descriptive commentaries on Whitman’s poems.
Conclusion
In class, most of you indicated that you have had prior workshops on media literacy and the related domain of information literacy. And as many of you also know, there are numerous open-access guides and tutorials on the web for further study. This post, and the work with Whitman in the weeks ahead, will respect the fact that you have this background by not repeating what you know in a learning module of some kind. The alternative is to dive into hands-on research in a robust, comprehensive, and well-constructed digital archive of literary materials. And this is what we will do!
Before class on Tuesday you are transcribing sentences from Whitman’s essay into our Google Doc. The textual history is in the Arhive, in Arthur Wrobel’s Democratic Vistas [1971], an electronic copy of the entry in Walt Whitman: An Encyclopedia, ed. Donald D. Cummings and J.R. LeMaster (New York: Garland Publishing, 1998) in The Walt Whitman Archive. Gen. ed. Matt Cohen, Ed Folsom, & Kenneth M. Price. I have copied the first part of the entry below so that we do not need to spend time on this during class:
This lengthy prose work, published in an eighty-four-page pamphlet in 1871, is comprised of a trilogy of essays Walt Whitman originally intended for publication in the Galaxy magazine. Two appeared in the Galaxy : “Democracy” in December 1867 and “Personalism” in May 1868; he submitted the third, “Orbic Literature,” to the Galaxy, but it did not appear.
The text of Democratic Vistas, which Whitman variously described as “memoranda” and “speculations,” some of which date to the middle 1850s, shows evidence of Whitman’s familiar propensity to tinker. Textual variations are evident in its several versions—from the “Rough Draft,” Galaxy, pamphlet, and Two Rivulets (1876) versions to the Specimen Days & Collect version. The various additions and deletions, however, are minor and do not alter Whitman’s purpose.