“Not knowing where one is coming out is an essential part of the experience of thinking.”
—Reuben Brower
This post is in lieu of a demonstration in class. I am documenting how my interest in a poem by Walt Whitman leads me from one place to another. Read this post before class. We will dedicate all of our class time to your own process of gathering materials for your first commentary on a poem by Walt Whitman.
When I posted On Literary Form, Production and Reception a little over two weeks ago I started with a look ahead:
In our work ahead with the poems of Walt Whitman, you will be learning how to make use of primary and secondary materials. You will be learning to navigate a digital archive. And you will be learning to enlarge your attention to matters of literary form, production, and reception. These three coordinates are especially useful for readers in college and beyond: 1) paying attention to the way a text is put together, 2) exploring the conditions (social, historical, biographical, ideological) in which a text was produced by an author; and 3) considering the tradition of commentary, or reception, of a text.
Since then, you have read the 1855 edition of Leaves of Grass, read and considered a selection of Whitman’s prose writing, and considered a range of poets and artists and readers responding to Whitman. In Walt Whitman and Democratic Literacy, posted a few days earlier, on September 18, as we approached our extended study of Walt Whitman’s poetry and prose, I quoted my own words (from the course syllabus):
reading, thinking, and writing are by definition creative activities that we learn and refine as we develop as human beings. In reading we learn to process language and information, access ideas, and open ourselves to minds and worlds that differ from our own; in thinking we learn to recognize patterns, make inferences, and evaluate evidence, as well as to access concepts and principles, understand cause and effect, temporality, and to consider moral and ethical questions in the complex situations we face in our lives; and in writing we discover and formulate and learn to share thoughts and ideas, communicate with different audiences, and learn to use language and discourse effectively in differing rhetorical contexts.
In the more recent Caution: Under Construction I focused attention on starting with a text, in this case Whitman’s speculative essay Democratic Vistas. My other purpose was to sound a cautionary note on approaching a text through the stories of other readers who have read Democratic Vistas. Our class discussions of Democratic Vistas were delightfully productive. The work we did with the passages that you chose from the text invited you to begin moving from your reading experience to the kinds of questions that come up in reading: questions about literary form, production, and reception.
In describing this work I was encouraging you to build out from your reading through primary and secondary materials in the digital archive. In class, I did a basic search for the primary document: Complete Prose Works > Democratic Vistas (pp. 203–58). I demonstrated how to find versions of the manuscript: Index of Works > Democratic Vistas. This path offered access to all known versions of the essay, organized by the section in which they appear on the Archive (20 primary documents). I noted that the search results included 5 secondary commentaries. I followed another pathway, too: Literary Manuscripts > Integrated Catalog of Walt Whitman’s Literary Manuscripts > Democratic Vistas (20 items). I then said, “Pay careful attention to the intertextual pathways above. They are ways to navigate the archive that you will be using during the next few weeks as you begin writing descriptive commentaries on Whitman’s poems.”
Making Connections
In other words, for nearly a month we have been preparing for the work you are doing right now. And as I have been saying and demonstrating––and as you have been doing in our in-class search workshops––there are many entry points for you as a reader and writer studying a poem by Walt Whitman. These pathways to materials in the Archive include the following.
- Home > Published Writings > Works
Clicking on a title allows a user to produce a list of all writings, published or unpublished, that are known to be related to a given work.
- Home > Integrated Catalog of Walt Whitman’s Literary Manuscripts
The Integrated Catalog combines the catalogs of each repository, describing all of Whitman’s literary manuscripts, organized around the concept of Whitman’s “works.”
- Home > Reviews (1855-1892)The reviews collected here include all of the items found in Walt Whitman: The Contemporary Reviews, ed. Kenneth M. Price (Cambridge University Press, 1996). This digital version of the print text includes more than 100 other reviews that were not included in that volume because of space considerations or because they had not been discovered.
- Home > Selected Criticism
This section of the Archive offers a sampling of copyrighted criticism, some out-of-copyright commentary, and selected full-length book studies by several scholars.
- Home > Bibliography
Includes articles, books, chapters of books, and poems about Whitman, published from 1838 to the present.
Of course knowing where to start will not take you where you are going. For as the teacher Reuben Brower reminds us in the epigraph to this essay, “Not knowing where one is coming out is an essential part of the experience of thinking.”
The “experience of thinking” is what college is (or should be) all about. The more thinking you do, the more competent your thinking will be. And good thinking, for the most part, leads to good (or effective) writing. People who teach talk about “critical” thinking and “creative thinking.” You will hear these terms a lot. But I prefer to start with the more basic term “thinking.” I start this way because creative thinking is most often critical and critical thinking is at its best creative.
One way to go about the process of writing about a poem by Walt Whitman is to follow the steps outlined in the assignment. Some students benefit from these kinds of outlines or rubrics. (This is why I write out the outline or rubric.) But genuine inquiry (or “research”) is a process that, for most of us, does not unfold in a step-by-step manner. Rather, the process involves the creative (and critical) work of making connections. It involves making abductive leaps (guesses) about particulars and relations that lead to finding out new information that unsettles the information you have already gathered.
Writing a literary commentary, then, is a process of thinking. I am especially fond of Annie Dillard’s concise description of the thinking and writing process in her book The Writing Life: “Make connections; let rip; dance where you can.” Making connections, letting your mind rip, and dancing where you can: this is precisely the creative work Emerson described for us as a mind “braced by labor and invention.” But remember what I said in class, it all begins with your interest. Your interest is where the process begins.
So that you will have the time and space to follow your interests during our time in class, in what follows, I am going to make some connections. I’m going to start with a poem I first mentioned in our reading of the first edition of Leaves of Grass, “The Sleepers.” Since I first read it, this poem has fascinated me. So let me see what I can find.
1. “The Sleepers”
A search in the Archive turns up “Sleepers, The (1855)” in Walt Whitman: An Encyclopedia that is available here. I learn that the poem had different titles, “Night Poem” (1856) and in the 1860 and 1867 editions the title is “Sleep-Chasing.” (Here I am documenting what I found out about the textual history.) There are a number of other fascinating details about the making of this poem in the entry by Burton Hatlen, including the context in which the poem was written and the reception of the poem among Whitman’s readers. (Let’s remember that these are the three elements of the literary commentary you will be writing.)
Another entry in the Encyclopedia is an account of the poem, “Thou Orb Aloft Full-Dazzling (1881).” From this overview by David B. Baldwin, I navigate from Literary Manuscripts > Integrated Catalog of Walt Whitman’s Literary Manuscripts > item: “Thou Orb Aloft” and I find myself looking at a two-page draft of a poem published first in 1881 as “A Summer Invocation.” This would be the poem that would be published later that year under the title “Thou Orb Aloft Full-Dazzling.”
2. “Miracles”
Another poem that interests me in Leaves of Grass is Miracles. What is a miracle, anyway? And what an amazing thing Whitman says in the second line of the poem, “I know nothing else but miracles.” And the last line! Wow.
These comments are what we called “marginal” comments (marginal thinking) But I find myself thinking beyond first thoughts to second thoughts. What is a “miracle” anyway? Perhaps more importantly for my purpose (as a reader of Whitman’s poem writing a commentary) what did this term miracle mean to people in the nineteenth century? Here I am trending to asking the kinds of questions we answer using what we called “annotation.” As I begin thinking, making connections, I recall that according to the New Testament, some guy named Jesus was known to be involved in a bunch of miracles. But wait, I am now thinking, what about Whitman and religion? Have other readers of Whitman asked this question?
The Walt Whitman Archive turns out to be an amazing resource for asking these kinds of questions. A term search in the Archive for religion dredges up 505 results. The results include “prophecy,” “The Revival Movement,” and “Metaphysics.” There are potentially useful lines from section 7 of Starting from Paumanock that turn up in the results as well:
I too, following many and follow’d by many, inaugurate a religion,
I descend into the arena,
(It may be I am destin’d to utter the loudest cries there, the win
ner’s pealing shouts,
Who knows? they may rise from me yet, and soar above every thing.)
Each is not for its own sake,
I say the whole earth and all the stars in the sky are for religion’s
sake.
I say no man has ever yet been half devout enough,
None has ever yet adored or worship’d half enough,
None has begun to think how divine he himself is, and how cer-
tain the future is.
I say that the real and permanent grandeur of these States must
be their religion,
Otherwise there is no real and permanent grandeur;
(Nor character nor life worthy the name without religion,
Nor land nor man or woman without religion.)
But where do I find myself with this gathering of information? Well, I have moved from where I was to where I am now: 1) I have found my way to another spectacular poem by the poet and 2) in asking about religious discourse (“miracles” etc.) I now have a search term: religion that leads me to an entry by David Kuebrich in the Walt Whitman: An Encyclopedia. The entry is useful for expanding my awareness of the social and cultural and religious discourse circulating in the nineteenth century, a discourse that may turn out to be of use for my understanding as I seek to get an overview of Whitman’s “religious vision” and what Whitman called in section 41 of “Song of Myself” (I am reminded by Kuerich) his “rough deific sketches.”
Now back to the poem and Leaves of Grass. I realize that I need to think about the poem in a book, and more specifically where Whitman placed the poem in the sequence. It turns out it is poem 21 in the 38-poem sequence “Autumn Rivulets.” It appears after Thought and before Sparkles from the Wheel. Then I notice something else. And it might (or might not) lead me somewhere (another connection, or not!).
There is a poem called To Him that was Crucified. Ok. So? Well, what I now know is that there is another poem in the Autumn Rivulets cluster of Leaves of Grass with a potentially related title To Him that was Crucified. I make an inference: the “Him” is the special guy in the Christian scriptures associated with miracles.
I am moving. It turns out, too, that there is in the results an encyclopedia entry on poem “Miracles” (1856). Reading this material leads me to another question: what are other instances of Whitman using the word “Miracles” in his poetry, prose, correspondence, or notebooks? A single-term search Whitman Archive > “Miracles” turns up 210 Results. Then I circle back to primary documents. I go to Home > Literary Manuscripts > Integrated Catalog of Walt Whitman’s Literary Manuscripts > Miracles and I am looking at 6 items: notebook entries [“Poem incarnating the mind”] and [9th av.] draft prose manuscript [“The Genuine Miracles of Christ”], manuscript page [“Such boundless and affluent souls”], and poem [“sea-cabbage”].
The title search includes a letter Marilla B. Minchen to Walt Whitman, 4 November 1891. It turns out that the admiring letter––her penmanship is spectacular––refers to the poem “Miracles” and includes other interesting information. (The pathway is Home > Letters > Correspondence.)
The search results also include a contemporary review of Leaves of Grass (Anonymous, 7 July 1860) that is, well, less admiring:
This is more decided language than we generally employ, and our readers may ask us for some justification of it. Let us remind them of Lord Macaulay’s description of Wycherley, which we can certainly apply to Walt Whitman. “His indecency is protected against the critics as a skunk is protected against the hunters. It is safe because it is too filthy to handle, and too noisome even to approach.” There are certain criminals whom even literary judges must try with closed doors, and our readers must deduce from our verdict that “the evidence is unfit for publication.” We say, then, deliberately, that of all the writers we have ever perused, Mr. Walt Whitman is the most silly, the most blasphemous, and the most disgusting; if we can think of any stronger epithets, we will print them in a second edition.
(Anonymous.) “Leaves of Grass.” The Walt Whitman Archive. Gen. ed. Matt Cohen, Ed Folsom, & Kenneth M. Price. Accessed 06 October 2026. <http://www.whitmanarchive.org>
Let’s consider this as an exemplary moment in the history of literary reception. It is a good example of a reader who is apparently challenged by Whitman. He considers Whitman an interloper, and he defends a set of cultural commonplaces about literature and decency and so on. (I am now connecting this to the passages in Democratic Vistas that we read about the people who are defending the status-quo and Whitman’s call for what he calls, rather elusively, “orbic literature.”)
But does all of this get me further down the road or closer to what I might be looking for? (Most often in this kind of research, after all, most of what one finds will not be used in the final commentary on the poem.) Then I go back to Commentary > Selected Criticism to look for some more information to understand the social and historical moment. In one of the results I find a reference to the term “spiritual” and to “spiritualism.”
So I pull my anchor and head out of the safe archival harbor onto the open sea of the world wide web. First, I settle on a Wikipedia page Spiritualism (beliefs) and another page Spiritualism (movement). The former has key terms that help me in my inquiry into my poem “place”Miracles,” terms such as “metaphysical,” “matter” and “spirit.” There is also a brief note about the 18th-century spiritualist Emanuel Swedenborg. I look for Swedenborg in the Archive (24 results) and find an article likely written by Whitman, Who was Swedenborg? The latter entry is fascinating, but the movement and the discourse seems to be Whitman adjacent, though it is the discourse of Whitman’s age.
Then I remembered that Whitman talks about religion and literature and culture in Democratic Vistas,
The altitude of literature and poetry has always been religion—and always will be. The Indian Vedas, the Nackas of Zoroaster, the Talmud of the Jews, the Old Testament, the Gospel of Christ and his disciples, Plato’s works, the Koran of Mohammed, the Edda of Snorro, and so on toward our own day, to Swedenborg, and to the invaluable contributions of Leibnitz, Kant and Hegel—these, with such poems only in which, (while singing well of persons and events, of the passions of man, and the shows of the material universe,) the religious tone, the consciousness of mystery, the recognition of the future, of the unknown, of Deity over and under all, and of the divine purpose, are never absent, but indirectly give tone to all—exhibit literature’s real heights and elevations, towering up like the great mountains of the earth.
This is one of two mentions of Swedenborg in Democratic Vistas. I find this out by doing a term search in the digital copy of the text. A rabbit hole, we often say. But then I am hearing the words of Adrienne Rich: “but these are the materials.” And I am sensing that this material will help me with talking about the poem I have chosen in the paragraph of my commentary that provides the social/historical/cultural context.
What I want, though, is to get closer to this discourse. I need to provide some descriptive context for the poem. The list of references and further reading in the Spiritualism (movement) page on Wikipedia is super helpful. And my take way is a book Miracles and Modern Spiritualism (1896) by the evolutionary biologist Alfred Russel Wallace that is available to read at the Internet Archive. Maybe I will find in this work a useful way to situate Whitman (and his poem) in the religious discourse of the time–especially since he is using religious discourse and referring to religions throughout his corpus.
Finding Commentary
The other domain of interest I need to follow to write an effective descriptive commentary on my poem “Miracles” is how the poem has been read by others(informed readers and critics) in the twentieth- and twenty first century.
One place to travel is the Archive bibliography. Bibliography > Title Search. “Miracles” turns up 12 results with some excellent secondary sources. Another other pathway is Home > Selected Criticism where I find access to a sampling of copyrighted criticism and some out-of-copyright commentary, and full-length book studies:
Books
- Killingsworth, M. Jimmie. Walt Whitman and the Earth: A Study in Ecopoetics (Iowa City: University of Iowa Press, 2004). HTML PDF (2 instances of word miracles)
- Allen, Gay Wilson, and Ed Folsom, ed. Walt Whitman & the World (Iowa City: University of Iowa Press, 1995). PDF (9 instances, mention of poems in lists)
Articles
- “Just when all seems lost, he is redeemed by the miracle of a touch: “He ahold of my hand has completely satisfied me.” Only the experience of love can confirm reality. The speaker’s newfound wisdom is an intuitive knowledge, beyond reason and verbal expression” (np).
- Walt Whitman: An Encyclopedia , ed. Donald D. Cummings and J.R. LeMaster (New York: Garland Publishing, 1998)
- Mattausch, Dena. “”Of the Terrible Doubt of Appearances” (1860).” The Walt Whitman Archive. Gen. ed. Matt Cohen, Ed Folsom, & Kenneth M. Price. Accessed 06 October 2026. <http://www.whitmanarchive.org>.
Beyond the Archive
For your commentaries, I encourage you to pack up some provisions and head out beyond the archive. The Mason Library is one of the places to go. The other destination is the wide open web.
Mason Library
Author name search Walt Whitman (About 49,600 results in Libraries Worldwide)
Filter to Keene State College Mason Library (About 250 results), print with call number and digital texts (ebooks)
Filter Books (92 entries)
Filter emusic
Articles in Database (Academic Journals, Magazines)
Walt Whitman Quarterly Review
Search for Whitman at EBSCO Database (373 results, filter for work to narrow)
Web Search (Google Chrome)
Author names search: Walt Whitman (About 14,600,000 results (0.27s) )
Author and title search Walt Whitman and “Miracles” (About 209,000 results (0.27s) )
*Google Scholar*
(Nb: Google Scholar is a useful research filter for students and scholars. Some of the items that you turn up will be full-text. digital and/or print, whereas other will need to be found in a database or, for more involved projects, using the Mason Library’s interlibrary loan services.)
Walt Whitman (articles: About 164,000 results (0.12 sec))
Walt Whitman and Miracles (sort by relevance 18,600 results (0.13 sec))
I look at the results, and turn up the following two (potentially useful) items:
- Whitman, Walt. The Sea Is a Continual Miracle: Sea Poems and Other Writings by Walt Whitman. Brandeis University Press, 2017. (anthology)
- Chesnick, Eugene. “Whitman and the Poetry of the Trillions.” Walt Whitman Quarterly Review 22.1 (1976): 14.
We could keep going. As there are places to go. But this is merely a preamble to your own work. On Thursday we will devote the entire class to your work. You can learn from another, I will circulate and answer questions and provide assistance.