Category Archives: Thinking and Making

Thinking and Writing in Context

It is difficult
to get the news from poems
                        yet men die miserably every day
                                                for lack
of what is found there.

––William Carlos Williams, from “Asphodel that Greeny Flower,” Journey to Love (1955)

Context I: Ideas and Intellectual Traditions

The context of our course is poetry and poetics; and in writing about poems and poets and the discourse of poetics you are part of an ongoing conversation that I have been pulling you into all semester. You have been reading (and writing about) poems and you have been reading prose statements by poets, critics, and theorists In an introductory college course, of course, you are not going to see all of the dimensions of this fascinating conversation.

But you can be aware of it; and you can use this awareness as you begin to write your way into a conversation about language, poetic form, and ideas. Read over the “Teacher Talks” I have written this semester; review the materials now archived on the “Workshops” page; and reread the poems we have read together: in reviewing the materials you will gain more confidence in what you have learned and you will likely see exciting connections across these primary and secondary materials.

It is also the case that materials we might gather under the category “poetry and poetics” is part of a more capacious field of human activity (literature and culture) that involves other kinds of experiences and thinking, whether psychological, social, political, moral, or philosophical. For instance, if I am writing a poem that engages with society I would eventually become aware of the intellectual context in which I am writing: for instance, I would find my way to the ideas of C. Wright Mills, Erving Goffman, and Pierre Bourdieu, three field-defining (and field-expanding) sociologists who shaped how we think about society, societal norms and institutions, and social change. If I am writing about the natural world, my writing would likely be informed by the intellectual context that shaped how we think in a more ecological way about the human and more-than-human world, a context that includes the ideas and empirical research of people such as Eugene Odum, James Lovelock, Rachel Carson, E. O. Wilson, Sylvia Earle, Vandana Shiva, and Robin Wall Kimmerer.

Context II: The Stories of our Lives

This course is organized around the premise that poems offer a vocabulary for knowing something about the world around us. This is the world that our experiences (and the humanities and science) teach us that we can never fully know. But to know (and to be) who we are is to know within the story we use to organize our lives.

Here is the neurologist and clinician Oliver Sacks explaining the constitutive place of story in our lives in a notable passage from his book The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat (1985).

We have, each of us, a life-story, an inner narrative — whose continuity, whose sense, is our lives. It might be said that each of us constructs and lives, a “narrative,” and that this narrative is us, our identities. If we wish to know about a man, we ask “what is his story — his real, inmost story?” — for each of us is a biography, a story. Each of us is a singular narrative, which is constructed, continually, unconsciously, by, through, and in us — through our perceptions, our feelings, our thoughts, our actions; and, not least, our discourse, our spoken narrations. Biologically, physiologically, we are not so different from each other; historically, as narratives — we are each of us unique.

One can read this alongside a passage from George Saunders’ book A Swim in a Pond in the Rain: In Which Four Russians Give a Master Class on Writing, Reading, and Life (2021), in which he argues not only that our singular inner narratives are constructed but they are also determinative. Our stories are evidence of how when make our inner lives we become subject to “a delusional gulf. . .between things as we think they are and things as they actually are:

The instant we wake the story begins: “Here I am. In my bed. Hard worker, good dad, decent husband, a guy who always tries his best. Jeez, my back hurts. Probably from the stupid gym.” And just like that, with our thoughts, the world gets made.

Or, anyway, a world gets made.

This world-making via thinking is natural, sane, Darwinian: we do it to survive. Is there harm in it? Well, yes, because we think in the same way that we hear or see: within a narrow, survival-enhancing range. We don’t see or hear all that might be seen or heard but only that which is helpful for us to see and hear. Our thoughts are similarly restricted and have a similarly narrow purpose: to help the thinker thrive.

All of this limited thinking has an unfortunate by-product: ego. Who is trying to survive? “I” am. The mind takes a vast unitary wholeness (the universe), selects one tiny segment of it (me), and starts narrating from that point of view. Just like that, that entity (George!) becomes real, and he is (surprise, surprise) located at the exact center of the universe, and everything is happening in his movie, so to speak; it is all, somehow, both for and about him. In this way, moral judgment arises: what is good for George is… good. What is bad for him is bad. (The bear is neither good nor bad until, looking hungry, it starts walking toward George.)

So, in every instant, a delusional gulf gets created between things as we think they are and things as they actually are. Off we go, mistaking the world we’ve made with our thoughts for the real world. Evil and dysfunction (or at least obnoxiousness) occur in proportion to how solidly a person believes that his projections are correct and energetically acts upon them.

Here is the thing: Saunder’s distinction between “a world” and “the world” is unsettling. It places demands on us we might otherwise ignore. It confronts us with how little we actually know about ourselves and the world. At the same time, it suggests that we can imagine through learning and growing and changing the ways we think and act in the world.

Poetry and Knowing

This space between worlds is of great interest to poets. Consider this poem by Denise Levertov, “Sojourns in a Parallel World,” from her 1996 collection Sands from the Well:

We live our lives of human passions,
cruelties, dreams, concepts,
crimes and the exercise of virtue
in and beside a world devoid
of our preoccupations, free
from apprehension—though affected,
certainly, by our actions. A world
parallel to our own though overlapping.
We call it “Nature”; only reluctantly
admitting ourselves to be “Nature” too.
Whenever we lose track of our own obsessions,
our self-concerns, because we drift for a minute,
an hour even, of pure (almost pure)
response to that insouciant life:
cloud, bird, fox, the flow of light, the dancing
pilgrimage of water, vast stillness
of spellbound ephemerae on a lit windowpane,
animal voices, mineral hum, wind
conversing with rain, ocean with rock, stuttering
of fire to coal—then something tethered
in us, hobbled like a donkey on its patch
of gnawed grass and thistles, breaks free.
No one discovers
just where we’ve been, when we’re caught up again
into our own sphere (where we must
return, indeed, to evolve our destinies)
—but we have changed, a little.

There are things we know, and there are things we don’t know. There is a world and there is the world beyond the world we have made. This is the condition of our lives. The poet Theodore Roethke, in his unforgettable poem The Waking, offers another instance of this interest in thinking and knowing. “We think by feeling. What is there to know?” In this case, what is offered is an assertion and a question, an untethering or breaking free that might lead us from where we are (or where we think we are) to someplace new.

As early as the first week of our class we were talking about feeling and thinking and knowing. You may remember, for instance, that I shared lines from Mary Oliver’s book-length poem The Leaf and the Cloud:

The pickerel
swims up from the pond from its roses of slow decay, and
looks at me
astonished.

What is it I need to know?

The gypsy moths, still caterpillars,
wrench themselves from the milky threads of birth
and set out on the long journey
in the shining tree.

What is it I don’t know that I need to know?

In these lines the speaker, reflecting on a “face to face” encounter with a pickerel, asks “What is it I need to know?” The speaker then describes the unfolding process of Lymantria dispar (the Gypsy Moth), which evolves through four distinct developmental stages––egg, larva, papa and adult (the moth). Did you know that during the larval stage of the life cycle of Lymantria, the female passes through six caterpillar instars, the male six?

Here Oliver enacts a process that leads from paying attention to asking questions. In the poem, the observation and description lead the speaker to a question about knowing. “What is it I don’t know that I need to know?” The questions that arise when we engage with ourselves and the world, the poem suggests, are about knowing: Who am I? Where am I? What am I doing here? What is going on? These are personal questions, about ourselves; but they are also philosophical questions, that have to do with understanding and making meaning.

Here is a recent poem by Patrick Rosal, Prayer for When I’m Lost. Note well the following lines,

prayer: give me a language for grief, jubilation, the gamut
of danger in waves. Let me name it aloud: Give this trouble

a shape. 

In their way of knowing, or in Patrick Rosal’s words, “giving trouble a shape,” poems unsettle the stories we live by. Not unlike other forms of art, a poem can offer us a vocabulary for the things we experience, and name within ourselves (say, grief). You might say they explore the less accessible dimensions of our inner lives. Let us remember the journey in Adrienne Rich’s Diving into the Wreck, the encounter of the narrator with

the thing I came for:
the wreck and not the story of the wreck
the thing itself and not the myth

This kind of seeking requires us to move beyond ourselves and into the process of becoming. For the poet Mary Oliver, this movement becomes possible when we make use of the two gifts we are given in the universe: “the ability to love and the ability to ask questions” (48). To love and to ask questions, she reminds us, expand and extend us. “Let me be who I am, and then some” (10), is how she pleads her case in the first essay of her collection Winter Hours, for “life is no narrow business” (12).

Poets on Knowledge and Uncertainty

(An installment in our our inquiry series.)

“how greatly the human mind is seduced by the vanity of the unequivocal.”

––Helen Vendler, “Loosed Quotes,” Inhabit the Poem: Last Essays (2025)

***

It is like what we imagine knowledge to be:

dark, salt, clear, moving, utterly free,

drawn from the cold hard mouth

of the world, derived from the rocky breasts

forever, flowing and drawn, and since

our knowledge is historical, flowing, and flown.

—Elizabeth Bishop, At the Fishhouses

*

We live in an orderly

universe of discoverable laws,

writes an intelligent alumna

in Harvard Magazine.

Bliss is belief. . . .

—Maxine Kumin, In the Absence of Bliss (In the Selected Poems, E-book through Interlibrary Loan)

*

“It’s exhilarating to be alive in a time of awakening consciousness; it can also be confusing, disorienting, and painful.”

—Adrienne Rich, “When We Dead Awaken: Writing as Re-Vision,” On Lies, Secrets, and Silence: Selected Prose 1966–1978 (KSC/Main Collection PS3535.I233 O6 1979)

*

“The unknown. . . . the unforetold, the unproven, that is what life is based on. Ignorance is the ground of thought. Unproof is the ground of action. If it were proven that there is no God there would be no religion… . But also if it were proven that there is a God, there would be no religion. . . . The only thing that makes life possible is permanent, intolerable uncertainty: not knowing what comes next. “
 

—Ursula K. Le Guin, The Left Hand of Darkness

Links and Streams

“I found when I had finished my new lecture that it was a very good house, only the architect had unfortunately omitted the stairs.”

––Ralph Waldo Emerson, Journals and Miscellaneous Notebooks

Among the thorny problems with using GenAI in your research is the broken link between the thinking and writing of others and your own. What happens is that information (facts, opinions, judgments) are decontextualized. In the academic writing you will be doing in the coming years you will be expected to include the stairs into the house of your thinking and writing so that a reader may join you in the collaboration at the center of meaningful intellectual work.

Walt Whitman. Photo credit: NYPL Digital Collections, Image ID: 437787

Web Literacy

In writing your literary commentaries you are using web pages and digital repositories (mostly the Walt Whitman Archive) as well as gathering information on the open web. We have talked about the skills of “surface” reading or skimming, as well as so-called “deep” reading. While the massive amount of information available on the web makes skimming a fundamental strategy––a strategy used by scholars, after all, in surveying the vast scholarly history of commentary on one subject or idea or question––deep (or critical) reading will often follow.  

As GenAI increasingly filters and organizes information we find on the open web it becomes increasingly clear that educated people need to think clearly and carefully about the information presented to them when they are seeking information or facts. In class we talked about peer review, and the role of experts in fields of expertise and knowledge.

My former colleague Mike Caulfield has some basic principles for searching for information on the web that he associates with “web literacy”: it includes 1) checking for previous fact-checking, 2) going upstream to the source, and 3) reading laterally. Here is how he elaborates his case in Web Literacy for Student Fact Checkers (2021):

What people need most when confronted with a claim that may not be 100% true is things they can do to get closer to the truth. They need something I have decided to call “moves.”

Check for previous work: Look around to see if someone else has already fact-checked the claim or provided a synthesis of research.

Go upstream to the source: Go “upstream” to the source of the claim. Most web content is not original. Get to the original source to understand the trustworthiness of the information.

Read laterally: Read laterally.[1] Once you get to the source of a claim, read what other people say about the source (publication, author, etc.). The truth is in the network.

Circle back: If you get lost, hit dead ends, or find yourself going down an increasingly confusing rabbit hole, back up and start over knowing what you know now. You’re likely to take a more informed path with different search terms and better decisions.

In general, you can try these moves in sequence. If you find success at any stage, your work might be done.

As information on the internet becomes increasingly organized for users by GenAI, these basic principles or habits will remain useful as you seek facts and information. They encompass some of what we have already talked about, including determining the provenance (origin, source) and the reliability (who and where) of the information, as well as the context (“truth is in the network”).

Links and Streams

When doing digital research it is useful to be aware of the distinction between how the information we access on the web is organized and distributed. What we find is determined by how we find it (or how it is found for us.)

Consider the link and the stream. As you continue your research, and poke around on the open web, you will be making use of hyperlinks or hypertext. In Education in the (Dis)Information Age, an essay I will use here to elaborate on using hyperlinks, the musicologist and digital media specialist Kris Schaffer writes that “if no one does this, or if they wait too long, the clickbait and conspiracy theories will win out.” One of the salient points Shaffer is making is that social media platforms

have worked hard to kill the hyperlink. Sure, there are plenty of links to click on, but they aren’t generated by users. Remember the difference between a link and a URL. I can paste a URL into a tweet or a Facebook post and it becomes clickable, but I cannot write in hypertext. I cannot annotate and link my writing with that of others. And including multiple URLs confuses the platforms! (It would be ironic that platforms whose financial well being is determined by clicks would have this problem — if we didn’t know better.) Social media are designed to share text, images, video, and articles, but not to write in hypertext — the language of the web. After all, if I actually click on all those links, I leave the platform… and take my ad-revenue-generating clicks with me.

The hyperlink is a simple and reliable method for digital citation that makes possible open access to distributed sites of information. It changes not only how we find things out, but at the same time how we read and think and write. The problem is that we have become increasingly habituated to proprietary platforms that only pretend to have our interests in mind. 

The problem is how we describe our digital lives. In simple terms, the metaphor of the web has been supplanted by the metaphor of the stream. In an essay in The Atlantic 2013: The Year “the Stream” Crested Alexi C. Madrigal writes, “The Stream has been the organizing metaphor for the web for the past several years.” Madrigal calls on Erick Schonfeld to explain how “Information is increasingly being distributed and presented in real-time streams instead of dedicated Web pages”:

Web companies large and small are embracing this stream. It is not just Twitter. It is Facebook and Friendfeed and AOL and Digg and Tweetdeck and Seesmic Desktop and Techmeme and Tweetmeme and Ustream and Qik and Kyte and blogs and Google Reader. The stream is winding its way throughout the Web and organizing it by nowness.

While these examples are dated (this was published in 2013) the enduring point is that the shift in the way we talk about and use the web matters. As the Iranian-Canadian blogger Hossein Derakshan writes in The Web We Have to Save, “The Stream now dominates the way people receive information on the web. Fewer users are directly checking dedicated webpages, instead getting fed by a never-ending flow of information that’s picked for them by complex –and secretive — algorithms.” Not unlike the meme “Kill Your TV,” a parallel instance for our age appears to be delete your Facebook account. The problem, as Derakshan explains, is the seductive efficiencies of digital technologies:

The Stream means you don’t need to open so many websites any more. You don’t need numerous tabs. You don’t even need a web browser. You open Twitter or Facebook on your smartphone and dive deep in. The mountain has come to you. Algorithms have picked everything for you. According to what you or your friends have read or seen before, they predict what you might like to see. It feels great not to waste time in finding interesting things on so many websites.

This situation is not unlike what Walker Percy described for us as “the loss of creature,” or the willingness to passively receive information and experience rather than actively struggling for it. After all, what exactly are we exchanging for efficiency? What we are missing? Percy would say agency and control. Indeed, the reach of what you are writing on a platform you control is not to be underestimated. Kris Schaffer proposes the following answer to the question:

Think about it this way. If I’m the first person to take a primary source, transcribe (or translate) it, and annotate it with hyperlinks, and my public, digital writing gains traction, it will fast become the go-to source at the top of the search results. My hyperlinks and commentary will become the portal to the resources that people engage to gain context, background, and nuance. It’s a tremendous responsibility, but also a tremendous opportunity, to connect my skills as an academic and a humanist to the issues of the day, in an attempt to bring nuance and truth to the public consciousness.

Shaffer concludes,

It’s time we brought back the hyperlink and learned how to really use it. It’s time we used information abundance to our advantage. And it’s time we disentangled our communications from platforms tuned for the spread of disinformation. The health of our democracies just might depend on it.

Photo credit: Photo credit: Bryson Hammer on Unsplash

In the context of academic writing, and with the advent of increasingly sophisticated GenAI platforms, the hyperlink makes visible a mind at work. As it happens, Ralph Waldo Emerson offers a nineteenth-century version of this visibility and the concept of networks–of words, thoughts, and texts––in his essay Quotation and Originality

All minds quote. Old and new make the warp and woof of every moment. There is no thread that is not a twist of these two strands. By necessity, by proclivity, and by delight, we all quote. We quote not only books and proverbs, but arts, sciences, religion, customs, and laws; nay, we quote temples and houses, tables and chairs by imitation.

Thinking and  Making. Architectonics. Houses and chairs. At the very least, we owe it to ourselves, and to our readers, to know where we are getting the information we use.

On Rediscovering the Network

What if we really did want to make durable and transparent connections across our experiences both in and outside the classroom? What if we really wanted to work together to build learning pathways, or a network, to integrate learning as well as to connect your college experiences to later stages of life or careers outside of school?

Consider the following examples using a search engine. First, a Google search, what some call “googling”:

In this case (unless you turn it off) the web browser gives you at the top of your results a GenAI summary:

The rewards and the risks of the GenAI Overview are many

When a user clicks on the link icon they are rewarded with a drop-down list of sources. But who (or what) chose those sources. A predictive algorithm. How do we rank these sources in relation to others in terms of accuracy and reliability and comprehensiveness? If we step out of the GenAI stream (though of course our feet are still wet, as the machine is sifting and sorting and ranking web sites in the results!) we come to The New York Public Library > Where to Start with Whitman (link #13 of 14,400,000 results)

This is, by most measures, a bit more promising. For example, the “Manifesto” offers insights into Whitman’s fascination with the body and bodily health.

Of course networked learning, and the metaphor of the web as a network, has deep roots. The metaphor of Indra’s Jeweled Net, in the Atharva Veda and is used by the Buddhist Tu- Shun (557-640 B.C.E.) to envision a vast net that includes jewels at each meeting point that represent individual life forms (atoms, cells, units of consciousness) that are interconnected; so that a change in one is reflected in all the others. The metaphor has been used, more recently, to describe the complex interconnected networks formed by relationships between objects in a system, in computation, ecological thinking, and in accounts of social networks.

What I am wondering about here is whether this ancient surmise is one antidote to the modern pathology of thinking predicated on individual parts that fuels the individualistic and atomistic patterns of behavior that make it so very difficult to imagine ways to imagine, if not change, the conditions of our lives.

On Writing a Literary Commentary

“Not knowing where one is coming out is an essential part of the experience of thinking.”

—Reuben Brower

This post is in lieu of a demonstration in class. I am documenting how my interest in a poem by Walt Whitman leads me from one place to another. Read this post before class. We will dedicate all of our class time to your own process of gathering materials for your first commentary on a poem by Walt Whitman.

When I posted On Literary Form, Production and Reception a little over two weeks ago I started with a look ahead:

In our work ahead with the poems of Walt Whitman, you will be learning how to make use of primary and secondary materials. You will be learning to navigate a digital archive. And you will be learning to enlarge your attention to matters of literary form, production, and reception. These three coordinates are especially useful for readers in college and beyond: 1) paying attention to the way a text is put together, 2) exploring the conditions (social, historical, biographical, ideological) in which a text was produced by an author; and 3) considering the tradition of commentary, or reception, of a text.

Since then, you have read the 1855 edition of Leaves of Grass, read and considered a selection of Whitman’s prose writing, and considered a range of poets and artists and readers responding to Whitman. In Walt Whitman and Democratic Literacy, posted a few days earlier, on September 18, as we approached our extended study of Walt Whitman’s poetry and prose, I quoted my own words (from the course syllabus):

reading, thinking, and writing are by definition creative activities that we learn and refine as we develop as human beings. In reading we learn to process language and information, access ideas, and open ourselves to minds and worlds that differ from our own; in thinking we learn to recognize patterns, make inferences, and evaluate evidence, as well as to access concepts and principles, understand cause and effect, temporality, and to consider moral and ethical questions in the complex situations we face in our lives; and in writing we discover and formulate and learn to share thoughts and ideas, communicate with different audiences, and learn to use language and discourse effectively in differing rhetorical contexts.

In the more recent Caution: Under Construction I focused attention on starting with a text, in this case Whitman’s speculative essay Democratic Vistas. My other purpose was to sound a cautionary note on approaching a text through the stories of other readers who have read Democratic Vistas. Our class discussions of Democratic Vistas were delightfully productive. The work we did with the passages that you chose from the text invited you to begin moving from your reading experience to the kinds of questions that come up in reading: questions about literary form, production, and reception.

In describing this work I was encouraging you to build out from your reading through primary and secondary materials in the digital archive. In class, I did a basic search for the primary document: Complete Prose Works > Democratic Vistas (pp. 203–58). I demonstrated how to find versions of the manuscript: Index of Works > Democratic Vistas. This path offered access to all known versions of the essay, organized by the section in which they appear on the Archive (20 primary documents). I noted that the search results included 5 secondary commentaries. I followed another pathway, too: Literary Manuscripts > Integrated Catalog of Walt Whitman’s Literary Manuscripts > Democratic Vistas (20 items). I then said, “Pay careful attention to the intertextual pathways above. They are ways to navigate the archive that you will be using during the next few weeks as you begin writing descriptive commentaries on Whitman’s poems.”

Making Connections

In other words, for nearly a month we have been preparing for the work you are doing right now. And as I have been saying and demonstrating––and as you have been doing in our in-class search workshops––there are many entry points for you as a reader and writer studying a poem by Walt Whitman. These pathways to materials in the Archive include the following.

  • Home > Published Writings > Works
    Clicking on a title allows a user to produce a list of all writings, published or unpublished, that are known to be related to a given work.
  • Home > Integrated Catalog of Walt Whitman’s Literary Manuscripts
    The Integrated Catalog combines the catalogs of each repository, describing all of Whitman’s literary manuscripts, organized around the concept of Whitman’s “works.”
  • Home > Reviews (1855-1892)The reviews collected here include all of the items found in Walt Whitman: The Contemporary Reviews, ed. Kenneth M. Price (Cambridge University Press, 1996). This digital version of the print text includes more than 100 other reviews that were not included in that volume because of space considerations or because they had not been discovered.
  • Home > Selected Criticism
    This section of the Archive offers a sampling of copyrighted criticism, some out-of-copyright commentary, and selected full-length book studies by several scholars.
  • Home > Bibliography
    Includes articles, books, chapters of books, and poems about Whitman, published from 1838 to the present.

Of course knowing where to start will not take you where you are going. For as the teacher Reuben Brower reminds us in the epigraph to this essay, “Not knowing where one is coming out is an essential part of the experience of thinking.”

The “experience of thinking” is what college is (or should be) all about. The more thinking you do, the more competent your thinking will be. And good thinking, for the most part, leads to good (or effective) writing. People who teach talk about “critical” thinking and “creative thinking.” You will hear these terms a lot. But I prefer to start with the more basic term “thinking.” I start this way because creative thinking is most often critical and critical thinking is at its best creative.

One way to go about the process of writing about a poem by Walt Whitman is to follow the steps outlined in the assignment. Some students benefit from these kinds of outlines or rubrics. (This is why I write out the outline or rubric.) But genuine inquiry (or “research”) is a process that, for most of us, does not unfold in a step-by-step manner. Rather, the process involves the creative (and critical) work of making connections. It involves making abductive leaps (guesses) about particulars and relations that lead to finding out new information that unsettles the information you have already gathered.

Writing a literary commentary, then, is a process of thinking. I am especially fond of Annie Dillard’s concise description of the thinking and writing process in her book The Writing Life: “Make connections; let rip; dance where you can.” Making connections, letting your mind rip, and dancing where you can: this is precisely the creative work Emerson described for us as a mind “braced by labor and invention.” But remember what I said in class, it all begins with your interest. Your interest is where the process begins.

So that you will have the time and space to follow your interests during our time in class, in what follows, I am going to make some connections. I’m going to start with a poem I first mentioned in our reading of the first edition of Leaves of Grass, “The Sleepers.” Since I first read it, this poem has fascinated me. So let me see what I can find.

1. “The Sleepers”

A search in the Archive turns up “Sleepers, The (1855)” in Walt Whitman: An Encyclopedia that is available here. I learn that the poem had different titles, “Night Poem” (1856) and in the 1860 and 1867 editions the title is “Sleep-Chasing.” (Here I am documenting what I found out about the textual history.) There are a number of other fascinating details about the making of this poem in the entry by Burton Hatlen, including the context in which the poem was written and the reception of the poem among Whitman’s readers. (Let’s remember that these are the three elements of the literary commentary you will be writing.)

Another entry in the Encyclopedia is an account of the poem, “Thou Orb Aloft Full-Dazzling (1881).” From this overview by David B. Baldwin, I navigate from Literary Manuscripts > Integrated Catalog of Walt Whitman’s Literary Manuscripts > item: “Thou Orb Aloft” and I find myself looking at a two-page draft of a poem published first in 1881 as “A Summer Invocation.” This would be the poem that would be published later that year under the title “Thou Orb Aloft Full-Dazzling.”

2. “Miracles”

Another poem that interests me in Leaves of Grass is Miracles. What is a miracle, anyway? And what an amazing thing Whitman says in the second line of the poem, “I know nothing else but miracles.” And the last line! Wow.

These comments are what we called “marginal” comments (marginal thinking) But I find myself thinking beyond first thoughts to second thoughts. What is a “miracle” anyway? Perhaps more importantly for my purpose (as a reader of Whitman’s poem writing a commentary) what did this term miracle mean to people in the nineteenth century? Here I am trending to asking the kinds of questions we answer using what we called “annotation.” As I begin thinking, making connections, I recall that according to the New Testament, some guy named Jesus was known to be involved in a bunch of miracles. But wait, I am now thinking, what about Whitman and religion? Have other readers of Whitman asked this question?

The Walt Whitman Archive turns out to be an amazing resource for asking these kinds of questions. A term search in the Archive for religion dredges up 505 results. The results include “prophecy,” “The Revival Movement,” and “Metaphysics.” There are potentially useful lines from section 7 of Starting from Paumanock that turn up in the results as well:

I too, following many and follow’d by many, inaugurate a religion,  
 I descend into the arena,
(It may be I am destin’d to utter the loudest cries there, the win 
 ner’s pealing shouts,
Who knows? they may rise from me yet, and soar above every thing.)


Each is not for its own sake,
I say the whole earth and all the stars in the sky are for religion’s  
 sake.

I say no man has ever yet been half devout enough,
None has ever yet adored or worship’d half enough,
None has begun to think how divine he himself is, and how cer- 
 tain the future is.

I say that the real and permanent grandeur of these States must  
 be their religion,
Otherwise there is no real and permanent grandeur;
(Nor character nor life worthy the name without religion,
Nor land nor man or woman without religion.)

But where do I find myself with this gathering of information? Well, I have moved from where I was to where I am now: 1) I have found my way to another spectacular poem by the poet and 2) in asking about religious discourse (“miracles” etc.) I now have a search term: religion that leads me to an entry by David Kuebrich in the Walt Whitman: An Encyclopedia. The entry is useful for expanding my awareness of the social and cultural and religious discourse circulating in the nineteenth century, a discourse that may turn out to be of use for my understanding as I seek to get an overview of Whitman’s “religious vision” and what Whitman called in section 41 of “Song of Myself” (I am reminded by Kuerich) his “rough deific sketches.”

Now back to the poem and Leaves of Grass. I realize that I need to think about the poem in a book, and more specifically where Whitman placed the poem in the sequence. It turns out it is poem 21 in the 38-poem sequence “Autumn Rivulets.” It appears after Thought and before Sparkles from the Wheel. Then I notice something else. And it might (or might not) lead me somewhere (another connection, or not!).

There is a poem called To Him that was Crucified. Ok. So? Well, what I now know is that there is another poem in the Autumn Rivulets cluster of Leaves of Grass with a potentially related title To Him that was Crucified. I make an inference: the “Him” is the special guy in the Christian scriptures associated with miracles.

I am moving. It turns out, too, that there is in the results an encyclopedia entry on poem “Miracles” (1856). Reading this material leads me to another question: what are other instances of Whitman using the word “Miracles” in his poetry, prose, correspondence, or notebooks? A single-term search Whitman Archive > “Miracles” turns up 210 Results. Then I circle back to primary documents. I go to Home > Literary Manuscripts > Integrated Catalog of Walt Whitman’s Literary Manuscripts > Miracles and I am looking at 6 items: notebook entries [“Poem incarnating the mind”] and [9th av.] draft prose manuscript [“The Genuine Miracles of Christ”], manuscript page [“Such boundless and affluent souls”], and poem [“sea-cabbage”].

The title search includes a letter Marilla B. Minchen to Walt Whitman, 4 November 1891. It turns out that the admiring letter––her penmanship is spectacular––refers to the poem “Miracles” and includes other interesting information. (The pathway is Home > Letters > Correspondence.)

The search results also include a contemporary review of Leaves of Grass (Anonymous, 7 July 1860) that is, well, less admiring:

This is more decided language than we generally employ, and our readers may ask us for some justification of it. Let us remind them of Lord Macaulay’s description of Wycherley, which we can certainly apply to Walt Whitman. “His indecency is protected against the critics as a skunk is protected against the hunters. It is safe because it is too filthy to handle, and too noisome even to approach.” There are certain criminals whom even literary judges must try with closed doors, and our readers must deduce from our verdict that “the evidence is unfit for publication.” We say, then, deliberately, that of all the writers we have ever perused, Mr. Walt Whitman is the most silly, the most blasphemous, and the most disgusting; if we can think of any stronger epithets, we will print them in a second edition.

(Anonymous.) “Leaves of Grass.” The Walt Whitman Archive. Gen. ed. Matt Cohen, Ed Folsom, & Kenneth M. Price. Accessed 06 October 2026. <http://www.whitmanarchive.org> 

Let’s consider this as an exemplary moment in the history of literary reception. It is a good example of a reader who is apparently challenged by Whitman. He considers Whitman an interloper, and he defends a set of cultural commonplaces about literature and decency and so on. (I am now connecting this to the passages in Democratic Vistas that we read about the people who are defending the status-quo and Whitman’s call for what he calls, rather elusively, “orbic literature.”)

But does all of this get me further down the road or closer to what I might be looking for? (Most often in this kind of research, after all, most of what one finds will not be used in the final commentary on the poem.) Then I go back to Commentary > Selected Criticism to look for some more information to understand the social and historical moment. In one of the results I find a reference to the term “spiritual” and to “spiritualism.”

So I pull my anchor and head out of the safe archival harbor onto the open sea of the world wide web. First, I settle on a Wikipedia page Spiritualism (beliefs) and another page Spiritualism (movement). The former has key terms that help me in my inquiry into my poem “place”Miracles,” terms such as “metaphysical,” “matter” and “spirit.” There is also a brief note about the 18th-century spiritualist Emanuel Swedenborg. I look for Swedenborg in the Archive (24 results) and find an article likely written by Whitman, Who was Swedenborg? The latter entry is fascinating, but the movement and the discourse seems to be Whitman adjacent, though it is the discourse of Whitman’s age.

Then I remembered that Whitman talks about religion and literature and culture in Democratic Vistas,

The altitude of literature and poetry has always been religion—and always will be. The Indian Vedas, the Nackas of Zoroaster, the Talmud of the Jews, the Old Testament, the Gospel of Christ and his disciples, Plato’s works, the Koran of Mohammed, the Edda of Snorro, and so on toward our own day, to Swedenborg, and to the invaluable contributions of Leibnitz, Kant and Hegel—these, with such poems only in which, (while singing well of persons and events, of the passions of man, and the shows of the material universe,) the religious tone, the consciousness of mystery, the recognition of the future, of the unknown, of Deity over and under all, and of the divine purpose, are never absent, but indirectly give tone to all—exhibit literature’s real heights and elevations, towering up like the great mountains of the earth.

This is one of two mentions of Swedenborg in Democratic Vistas. I find this out by doing a term search in the digital copy of the text. A rabbit hole, we often say. But then I am hearing the words of Adrienne Rich: “but these are the materials.” And I am sensing that this material will help me with talking about the poem I have chosen in the paragraph of my commentary that provides the social/historical/cultural context.

What I want, though, is to get closer to this discourse. I need to provide some descriptive context for the poem. The list of references and further reading in the Spiritualism (movement) page on Wikipedia is super helpful. And my take way is a book Miracles and Modern Spiritualism (1896) by the evolutionary biologist Alfred Russel Wallace that is available to read at the Internet Archive. Maybe I will find in this work a useful way to situate Whitman (and his poem) in the religious discourse of the time–especially since he is using religious discourse and referring to religions throughout his corpus.

Finding Commentary

The other domain of interest I need to follow to write an effective descriptive commentary on my poem “Miracles” is how the poem has been read by others(informed readers and critics) in the twentieth- and twenty first century.

One place to travel is the Archive bibliography. Bibliography > Title Search. “Miracles” turns up 12 results with some excellent secondary sources. Another other pathway is Home > Selected Criticism where I find access to a sampling of copyrighted criticism and some out-of-copyright commentary, and full-length book studies:

Books

  • Killingsworth, M. Jimmie. Walt Whitman and the Earth: A Study in Ecopoetics (Iowa City: University of Iowa Press, 2004). HTML PDF (2 instances of word miracles)
  • Allen, Gay Wilson, and Ed Folsom, ed. Walt Whitman & the World (Iowa City: University of Iowa Press, 1995). PDF (9 instances, mention of poems in lists)

    Articles
  • “Just when all seems lost, he is redeemed by the miracle of a touch: “He ahold of my hand has completely satisfied me.” Only the experience of love can confirm reality. The speaker’s newfound wisdom is an intuitive knowledge, beyond reason and verbal expression” (np).
  • Walt Whitman: An Encyclopedia , ed. Donald D. Cummings and J.R. LeMaster (New York: Garland Publishing, 1998)
  • Mattausch, Dena. “”Of the Terrible Doubt of Appearances” (1860).” The Walt Whitman Archive. Gen. ed. Matt Cohen, Ed Folsom, & Kenneth M. Price. Accessed 06 October 2026. <http://www.whitmanarchive.org>.

    Beyond the Archive

For your commentaries, I encourage you to pack up some provisions and head out beyond the archive. The Mason Library is one of the places to go. The other destination is the wide open web.

Mason Library

Author name search Walt Whitman (About 49,600 results in Libraries Worldwide)
Filter to Keene State College Mason Library (About 250 results), print with call number and digital texts (ebooks)
Filter Books (92 entries)
Filter emusic

Articles in Database (Academic Journals, Magazines)
Walt Whitman Quarterly Review 
Search for Whitman at  EBSCO Database (373 results, filter for work to narrow)

Web Search (Google Chrome)
Author names search: Walt Whitman (About 14,600,000 results (0.27s) )
Author and title search Walt Whitman and “Miracles” (About 209,000 results (0.27s) )

*Google Scholar*
(Nb: Google Scholar is a useful research filter for students and scholars. Some of the items that you turn up will be full-text. digital and/or print, whereas other will need to be found in a database or, for more involved projects, using the Mason Library’s interlibrary loan services.)

Walt Whitman (articles: About 164,000 results (0.12 sec))
Walt Whitman and Miracles (sort by relevance 18,600 results (0.13 sec))

I look at the results, and turn up the following two (potentially useful) items:

  • Whitman, Walt. The Sea Is a Continual Miracle: Sea Poems and Other Writings by Walt Whitman. Brandeis University Press, 2017. (anthology)
  • Chesnick, Eugene. “Whitman and the Poetry of the Trillions.” Walt Whitman Quarterly Review 22.1 (1976): 14.

We could keep going. As there are places to go. But this is merely a preamble to your own work. On Thursday we will devote the entire class to your work. You can learn from another, I will circulate and answer questions and provide assistance.

How to Live, What to Do

Last evening the moon rose above this rock
Impure upon a world unpurged.
The man and his companion stopped
To rest before the heroic height.

Coldly the wind fell upon them
In many majesties of sound:
They that had left the flame-freaked sun
To seek a sun of fuller fire.

Instead there was this tufted rock
Massively rising high and bare
Beyond all trees, the ridges thrown
Like giant arms among the clouds.

There was neither voice nor crested image,
No chorister, nor priest. There was
Only the great height of the rock
And the two of them standing still to rest.

There was the cold wind and the sound
It made, away from the muck of the land
That they had left, heroic sound
Joyous and jubilant.

––Wallace Stevens, Ideas of Order (1936)

“Books are to be call’d for, and supplied, on the assumption that the process of reading is not a half-sleep, but, in highest sense, an exercise, a gymnast’s struggle; that the reader is to do something for himself, must be on the alert, must himself or herself construct indeed the poem, argument, history, metaphysical essay—the text furnishing the hints, the clue, the start or framework. Not the book needs so much to be the complete thing, but the reader of the book does. That were to make a nation of supple and athletic minds, well-train’d, intuitive, used to depend on themselves, and not a few coteries of writers.”

—Walt Whitman, “Democratic Vistas”

Introduction

Thank you for sharing your experiences using Generative AI (GenAI) in school. Your comments were remarkably consistent. As a few of you pointed out, every one of us is already using GenAI. It is embedded in many of the digital tools and programs we use every day, from the images we capture using the camera on our smart phones to the autocorrect suggestions in a text or email, to the algorithms that drive the content on social media feeds, not to mention the now ubiquitous and embedded tools in our digital experiences, including autocorrect, spell-checkers, chat bots of one kind or another, and search engine results.

For the purposes of a first-year college thinking and writing class our focus will be on the AI tools that generate text. These statistical large language models (LLMs) are programmed to recognize abstract patterns that generate what is most probable based on those patterns. These tools are therefore being used in routine transactional communication tasks in the workplace—generating meeting minutes, routine reports and memos, social media text, customer service transactions, translation, market research and analysis, and so on.

But in a college classroom, designed to develop particular content knowledge and skills, there are additional considerations. Because an LLM is run on a machine, it has no way of determining what is true or false. It has no expertise. It has no experience. It has no understanding, embodied knowledge, or semantic awareness. It cannot think or feel.

GenAI programs operate, for the most part, without an ethical or moral framework. A GenAI tool does not distinguish between accurate/inaccurate or biased/unbiased information, and it should not be surprising that it recombines accurate source information in ways that generate inaccurate statements. It makes things up. Rather than using a metaphor and calling these “hallucinations,” let’s just say that these inaccurate statements are part and parcel of what these programs do.

In addition to formulating our guidelines for the class, based on your previous classroom experiences, I recommend that you become familiar with the Modern Language Association (MLA) Student Guide to AI Literacy. In this document you will find the following statement on “AI Literacy”:

AI Literacy

Ethical and effective use of GenAI technologies is emerging as an essential skill that students must develop in order to live, learn, and work. Yet GenAI comes with potential pitfalls for students–from the risk of being accused of academic misconduct to missing out on foundational skills in reading, writing, research, and learning.

Developing literacy with a tool means becoming a more skilled and thoughtful user of that tool. For example, developing literacy in reading means being able to reread, tackle increasingly difficult texts, and do research in order to further build your capability as a reader. Literacy also assumes you have enough knowledge to question and evaluate what you are studying.

Similarly, developing AI literacy requires that you learn certain basics about how GenAI works, how to use it, and how to evaluate its output. You should also learn when not to use it. Developing GenAI literacy should be your starting point for using this technology. When you build skills and habits for using GenAI ethically and effectively you will establish yourself as a thoughtful creator and consumer of GenAI content as technologies change over time.

The responsible and effective use of emergent GenAI tools requires students to be thoughtful and deliberate.

How to Live, What to Do

Consider the following example. After selecting and placing the poem “How to Live, What to Do,” by Wallace Stevens, as one of two epigraphs for this post, I opened a search window on my Google Chrome browser to refresh my memory of the poem’s date of publication. (Rather than getting up from my desk to pull the volume off my bookcase.). Here is the search result on Google search:

The GenAI Overview is incorrect. And mores the pity, as a large percentage of users would likely accept the results. (Note well the deceptive and seductive certainty of the output, “did not publish a poem” and “no such poem.”) As an avid reader of poems, with a doctorate in American literature and culture and decades of reading and teaching poetry, I was aware that this overview was wrong. (As it happens, I have also read the Koethke book, and know that he took his title from the poem.) But if you don’t have background or expertise, well, again, mores the pity.

There is such a poem. But remember, my question was about when the poem was published, and in which of Stevens’ volumes of poetry. Then curiosity got the best of me. And I clicked on “Dive Deeper in AI Mode.” Below is the prompt and the answer:

By “going deeper,” the mode of inquiry (GenAI) produced a new finding: Lo! Wallace Stevens did write and publish a poem entitled “How to Live, What to Do.” But. I studied Stevens in graduate school, and have taught his work for decades; and I knew that this was among his earlier poems. So I got up and pulled the Collected Poetry and Prose off the shelf and looked at the Table of Contents to refresh my memory. And there it was, nestled between “Lions in Sweden” and “Some Friends from Pascagoula” in the sequence of poems in Ideas of Order, a book published in 1936.

(As a follow up, I retyped my query into Google search and in this instance the GenAI “Overview” reported that the poem appears in the 1942 collection Parts of the World, though the table of contents of that book does not include the poem. (“AI responses may include mistakes”. . . .)

The Use of AI in Teaching and Learning

One of you wrote to me in an email that “we should avoid the use of AI as much as possible. I believe that everything GenAI does for us makes us lose a skill that we could greatly benefit from.”

I’m not sure I could say this better. The example above illustrates well the problem. I might begin to define the problem as the wide availability of a (seductive) technology that is unreliable. In order to check the accuracy of the information generated a user will in most cases spend far more time vetting the information than if the user simply used a more reliable methods of searching for information––methods, not incidentally, we will be practing next week.

But the more I think about the problem the more I suspect that the use of GenAI will diminish the opportunity for people (in the present case, you, as students) to experience the pleasure and rewards of curiosity––the formalized curiosity that the writer and sociologist Zora Neale Hurston once called “poking and prying with a purpose.” (She makes this widely-cited remark about research in her lovely memoir, Dust Tracks on a Road, first published in 1942.)

So maybe it is not so much “losing” a skill as making it less possible to access the opportunity to experience the creative mind at work. “There is then creative reading as well as creative writing,” the nineteenth-century American thinker Ralph Waldo Emerson writes in his singular 1836 oration The American Scholar. He continues, “When the mind is braced by labor and invention, the page of whatever book we read becomes luminous with manifold allusion. Every sentence is doubly significant, and the sense of our author is as broad as the world.” We might compare Emerson’s expanding circle of the self (“broadness”) to Whitman’s aspiration for the reader in the second epigraph to this class note. “Not the book needs so much to be the complete thing, but the reader of the book does.”

Emerson and Whitman are chasing a simple formulation, really: it is that reading, thinking, and writing are by definition creative activities that we learn and refine as we develop as human beings. In reading we learn to process language and information, to access ideas, and open ourselves to minds and worlds that differ from our own; in thinking we learn to recognize patterns, make inferences, and evaluate evidence, as well as to access concepts and principles, understand cause and effect, temporality, and to consider moral and ethical questions in complex situations we face in our lives; and in writing we discover and formulate and learn to share thoughts and ideas, communicate with different audiences, and learn to use language and discourse effectively in differing rhetorical contexts.

These creative activities––reading, thinking, research, writing––are what this class is all about.

What can you do with this poem? How does this poem help you think? How do you think with a poem? What can you do with what you know? These questions bring to mind another comment that one of you made, that “using AI completely defeats the purpose of any assignment because it does it for you.” What is the purpose of the reading, thinking, and writing assignments in this class? The purpose––and forgive me for reaching for more abstract language to capture the purpose––is to engage you in activities that constitute you, as a writer and as a thinking subject with agency in the world.

Finally, in your comments on AI there surfaced a prescient question about the very definition of writing itself. After all, what is writing? The question is helpful for us. For GenAI produces text, not thinking and not writing. Texts that are machine-generated output have no intent, provenance, or reliable accuracy. Writing as output is different from writing as constitutive. GenAI makes you dependent on Natural Language Processing (NLP) to generate language and in the process robs you of one of your greatest gifts as a human being: the ability to use language. I can’t help but think of the conclusion of Walker Percy in the essay we read and annotated during the first week of class, “The Loss of Creature.” As you will remember, he writes, that the loss of our autonomy (he uses the term “sovereignty”) is “a consequence of the seduction of the layman by science. The layman will be seduced. . .as long as he waives his sovereign rights as a person and accepts his role of consumer as the highest estate to which the layman can aspire” (63).

As you navigate the use of GenAI in forms of intellectual work, and develop a functional level of AI Literacy, I encourage you to consider the cautionary words of one of your classmates. “If you get all your help from AI,” they write, “it can damage your ability to ask for help from another human. AI doesn’t judge or think, it doesn’t have a face or a social standing.” This is a brilliant and haunting observation that should give all of us pause.

Acceptable and Unacceptable Uses

While some of your groups were more critical of these emergent technological tools, others were more willing to approach the use of GenAI with less skepticism. Using language from your experiences using GenAI, sent to me for writing specific guidelines for our class, please find below a list of acceptable and unacceptable uses. I also include below guidelines for citing GenAI using the Modern Language Association (MLA) style guide and the relevant excerpt from the Keene State Policy on Academic Honesty.

Acceptable uses

  • Exploration of Ideas, including the use of AI to explore topics and generate initial ideas, developing sample statements of purpose (or thesis statements) through AI-assisted questioning, creating outlines or possible organizational sequences of ideas;
  • Research Assistance, including clarifying complex concepts or terminology, defining search terms, generating a list of questions to focus a line of inquiry, or compiling a first draft of an annotated bibliography or list of works cited;
  • Writing Process Support, including reviewing grammar and style, suggesting sentence revisions for clarity, or receiving feedback on the organization of a draft.

Unacceptable uses

  • Generating Primary Content, including having GenAI write substantial portions of assignments, submitting AI-generated text as original work, using GenAI to complete an entire assignment;
  • Doing Critical Analysis, including the use of GenAI-generated analysis or interpretations, or using GenAI conclusions rather than thinking and reasoning on one’s own;
  • Failing to disclose AI, including misrepresenting GenAI-generated content as your own intellectual work, or using GenAI to complete writing tasks designed to evaluate specific skills (such as explication, analysis, or interpretation.

If you are using an GenAI tool to think or write for you, you are violating the trust of your teacher, who is dedicated to improving your intellectual capacities; you are betraying your classmates, and failing to contribute to the learning community in our classroom; and you are transgressing the ethical values that motivate genuine academic inquiry.

Guidelines for Citing AI

Honesty and transparency are core principles of academic inquiry. You are therefore responsible for your writing and for disclosing the use of any assistance you received in completing your academic work. Any and all use of GenAI must be appropriately documented using standard academic citation guidelines

The Modern Language Association (MLA) Style Center has guidelines for citing generative AI. In this class we will follow the MLA guidelines:

  • cite a GenAI tool whenever you paraphrase, quote, or incorporate into your own work any content (whether text, image, data, or other) that was created by it;
  • acknowledge all functional uses of the tool (like editing your prose or translating words) in a note, your text, or another suitable location;
     
  • and be judicious in vetting each secondary source a GenAI cites.

    Here is an example of how to cite an in text citation or paraphrase: (“Describe the symbolism”):
  • Works Cited Entry “Describe the symbolism of the green light in the book The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald” prompt. ChatGPT, 13 Feb. version, OpenAI, 8 Mar. 2023, chat.openai.com/chat.
  • Works-Cited-List Entry “In 200 words, describe the symbolism of the green light in The Great Gatsby” follow-up prompt to list sources. ChatGPT, 13 Feb. version, OpenAI, 9 Mar. 2023, chat.openai.com/chat.

The Keene State College Academic Honesty Policy statement on generative AI

Generative artificial intelligence (AI) is an emerging tool in teaching, learning, and workplace environments.  The College strongly encourages instructors to establish and to clearly articulate course policies governing students’ appropriate use of generative AI, if any. Generative AI tools may not be used in the completion of coursework unless the instructor specifically authorizes their use.  If an instructor approves the use of generative AI for coursework, any use must be properly cited, as defined by this Academic Honesty Policy. The College encourages our entire academic community to consider the ethical implications of uploading copyrighted work to generative AI programs.