Browse Tag

thinking and writing

What Was ITW

What is the relationship between thinking and writing? The problem with asking this question is that most responses begin with commonplace practices teaching writing in school. Students in primary and secondary grades experience writing mostly through routine tasks that promote mastery of a discrete set of skills. College undergraduates are asked to produce essays that demonstrate whether or not they have a working understanding of course content. Graduate students produce readings of books and other artifacts that apply ready-made protocols to generate arguments as a quantitative measure for professional advancement. And professors, having internalized the imperative to publish or perish, produce reams of writing that very few people have reason to read.

The situation is a classic case of what the critic Kenneth Burke once called the beauracratization of the imaginative—a phrase, as he put it, “as bungling as the situation it seeks to describe.” In most colleges and universities, in fact, first-year students find themselves writing essays with little to no intellectual investment; and their teachers find themselves reading essays that no one should ever be asked to read. It is no surprise that tenure-stream faculty routinely abandon the first-year course while effectively ignoring the working conditions of the contingent faculty they hire to teach it.

In what follows I look back at an alternative model: a curricular project that replaced a first-year English writing requirement. Among the salient features of this multi-decade project at Keene State College was our attempt to situate writing as a primary intellectual activity across academic disciplines. Our model was built around the idea that students’ writing ability is largely a function of their ability to think. Hence the challenge was how a first-year course might re-imagine reading, thinking and writing as a process of reasoning. One of the constitutive features of the project, as I elaborate below, was a convergence of ideas from writing studies and developmental psychology. My motivation is in part to recount the singular moment that produced a generative first-year writing experience, as well as to consider some of the reasons that the course persisted for two decades—a remarkable run that surely had something to do with the integrity of the project and the intellectual investments of those of us who nurtured it.

From a Culture of Complaint to a Culture of Conversation

Institutional changes are notoriously complex. Hence my story of the activities and initiatives that contributed to this curricular transformation will be truncated at best. Though I should say right off that a college like Keene State is relatively small, and therefore vulnerable to people with ideas and initiative. In fact, the genesis of the Integrative Thinking and Writing (ITW) course, as I will elaborate in the first part of this reflection, was inextricable from a long foreground: a multi-year campus-wide conversation about the teaching and learning of effective writing. This conversation would culminate in pilot sections of ITW course and its eventual implementation as one of two foundational courses in Keene State College’s Integrative Studies Program (ISP).

In the early 1990s faculty from the then tripartite divisions of the College––sciences, professional studies and humanities––convened a “Writing Task Force” to talk about thinking and writing. Our Writing Task force was made up of people who shared the conviction that we need to challenge students with authentic writing across four years of an undergraduate education. (We were people who had come to Keene State with the belief that the study of the liberal arts should not be a privilege for only those able to attend a private school.) The Task Force on Writing was a tour de force: we sponsored dozens of workshops to assist faculty around such issues as creating good writing assignments, preventing plagiarism, and techniques for commenting on students’ papers. The Task Force initiated campus-wide research projects and newsletters; facilitated conversation about writing on campus; supported and advanced writing-across-the curriculum projects; supported faculty teaching the course to improve the practice of teaching writing; and collaborated with the undergraduate students in the College’s Writing Center.

In 2004 the Task Force refined its mission and articulated a vision for writing consistent with Keene State’s mission as a liberal arts college: that students should be able to use writing for a variety of purposes: to wrestle with complex ideas; to compose well-supported arguments; to express themselves creatively; to communicate effectively; to demonstrate learning; and to better understand what it means to write both as members of an academic discipline and as liberally educated people. By design the Task Force did not advocate for a particular course or curriculum: it was decidedly ecumenical and deliberately not engaged with curriculum. Instead, it offered the campus a broad vision for writing at the College: “In order for Keene State students to learn how to use writing for a variety of purposes, they must be provided with sustained writing instruction. Writing should permeate the curriculum rather than remain relegated to English 101 and the few discipline-specific writing courses now offered,” we insisted. Hence the practical work of the Task Force was sustaining a campus-wide conversation about the teaching of writing.

Though of course as faculty teaching in academic programs our work was curriculum adjacent. In fact, among the generative discussions sparked by the Task Force was about the relative effectiveness of our required English 101 course. In a Task Force Newsletter, we asked the entire campus community to think seriously about whether our English 101 course was a good idea. Based on a traditional model of required first-year writing courses, students in English 101 were asked to write five essays, most of which were narrative compositions that, to our minds, neither furthered students’ research skills nor asked them to investigate meaningful academic issues. How might we get more faculty involved in teaching writing and curious about the relationship between thinking and writing in their own academic fields of study?

More workshops and newsletters, we realized. could only take us so far. So we set to work on how we might engage more faculty in the conversation. In 2002 Dr. Phyllis Benay, professor of Interdisciplinary Studies and Director of the Center for Writing, Dr. Kirsti Sandy, then associate professor of English, and Dr. me, professor of English and American Studies, designed and received external funding for a faculty institute on the teaching of writing. With generous multi-year funding from Boston’s Calderwood Foundation, our Calderwood Institute set out to improve student writing by helping faculty across all disciplines become better teachers of writing.For over a decade, the Institute offered eight Keene State faculty members each year an immersive week engaging in reading, reflection, and dialogue around more effective ways to teach, assign, and evaluate student writing. Drawing on readings about student writing and its relationship to learning, participants examined what we know about students as writers, and the relationship between writing and cognitive development. Participants then worked individually and collaboratively (as well as with the three facilitators) throughout the academic year to transform their own writing assignments, methods of evaluation, and course design.

We asked participants, first, to locate themselves as writers––to critically examine the link between what they value in student writing and the disciplines and institutional contexts that have shaped these values; we then asked them to locate the student––to read and discuss selected research and theory on student learning and the teaching of writing; and then the participants were encouraged participants to 1) develop a working vocabulary in concepts associated with the teaching of writing; 2) approach writing as a discipline with a history that can be applied to their disciplinary contexts and objectives; 3) critically examine the role of writing in at least one of their courses; and 4) design (or re-design) a sequence of writing assignments in one course based on their reading and thinking in the institute.

The overarching pedagogical strategy of the Institute was encouraging faculty to forge connections between their own writing process and practice and the teaching of writing in their classes. As a professor of Anthropology, Rosemary Gianno, wrote in a post-Institute reflection, “It drove home to me how much writing itself is a way of learning, not just a way of demonstrating learning. While I have myself learned a lot from the writing I have done I was never conscious enough of this process to convey that or emphasize that in my classes. This new way of thinking about the role of writing in learning provides a sounder basis for its use in the classroom.” Another participant, a professor of Sociology, Peggy Walsh, voiced the sense of the excitement we were all feeling after a week together in the summer Institute. “As I finalize my syllabi, I have been reviewing my materials from the Writing Institute, reflecting on what I learned and making changes—some subtle, some dramatic—to my assignments. I am excited to share these ideas with students.” Could we have asked for more?

Over the duration of the multi-year Calderwood project we worked with close to seventy-five members of the faculty. One of the questions we were asking participants emerged out of the intellectual streams feeding into the project: how do we think about the relationship between cognition and writing? Given the nature of this question, it will come as no surprise that one of the project leaders, Phyllis, had a doctorate in developmental psychology. Soon after I began spending time with her, I recall, she stopped by to visit me in Parker Hall. I watched her eyes scan the one-thousand or so books lined up on the shelves that lined the walls of my office; then a week later she told me that she had caught sight of the blood-red spine of Robert Keegan’s The Evolving Self: Problem and Process in Human Development (1982) and had left wondering about when (and why) I had the book. As it happened, I picked it up at a used book sale in the University District of Seattle, during graduate school, at a time I was thinking through the very idea of the “self,” reading in the work of the American pragmatists Charles Sanders Peirce and William James for my thesis, and considering the history and construction of modern subjectivity with the philosopher Charles Taylor––in another book that also lived on my office shelf––The Sources of the Self: The Making of Modern Identity (1989).

Keegan, a professor at Harvard University, offers a persuasive model for thinking about meaning-making as a lifelong activity that evolves through a series of life stages. Not incidentally, Phyllis had spent time in the classroom with Keegan, and in her doctoral thesis had applied the developmental theory of William Perry, who argued that people’s thinking and understanding evolve over time. Perry’s focus on cognitive development in college students, in conversation with process-based writing theories of scholars such as Peter Elbow, proved to be central to the idea that was ITW: that is, student thinking and writing, ideally, would evolve from more simplisitic (dualistic) thinking to more complex (multiplist and contextual) thinking.

In our faculty workshops we intentionally mapped Perry’s schema onto the thinking and writing process. In the process we were formulating an audacious faith: that students would find in the struggle of thinking through writing a less authority-dependent outlook with the capacity to take their writing as “object” (that is, to examine) instead of being “subject” to (that is, embedded in) the writing. This movement from unreflective dependence to reflective autonomy would unfold differently for every student, we were aware, and the developmental schema would (ideally, of course) offer students a workshop in the thinking (and writing) they would be expected to do through their four years of college––and, if we did our work well, on into their lives as adults. The ITW project had in mind from the outset the idea of transfer: that is, how was the thinking and writing students were experiencing in going to show up in writing experiences beyond the first year?

And so there we were. We were planning courses with the idea that in a semester we could somehow move students from dualism, through multiplism, to contextualism. Or at the very least, we could try! Our students were like most young people, quite naturally thinking dualistically, and therefore mildly if not militantly resistant to the value of writing for a teacher who (of course!) knows everything already. Many of them were habitual users of signal phrases of the multiplist (“in my opinion” and “personally”). Many of them were summarizing and repeating claims to avoid what they think or do not think, or know or do not know, as we introduced them to the idea of discourse. And many of them were groping their way, as we all do, toward the contextualist recognition that there might be something to contribute to any conversation, and that their voices might become part of the multiple perspectives circulating around the questions and ideas and contexts they were navigating in their lives and at school.

From a Culture of Conversation to a Culture of Commitment

The movement from a culture of complaint to a culture of conversation led us to what we might not have envisioned when we began this work: the very real possibility of a campus commitment to the teaching of writing. At the time, the faculty was turning its attention (once again) to a revision of the general education program, and I volunteered for the committee. But my first job of work, as chair of the department of English, was to convince my literature colleagues to give up the freshman composition course. While the irony of people arguing for a course that no one wanted to teach is worth noting here, we all knew the shortcomings of the first-year writing course—a course that defined writing as a set of discrete skills that would be acquired in a fifteen-week term in preparation for college-level reading and writing. It was our good fortune, too, that a few years earlier we had hired a talented specialist in writing (Kirsti) who, like me, had graduate-school experience in writing program administration. We were also blessed with key administrative support when it mattered most.

The fundamental premise of the ITW course was significantly different than English 101. ITW would ask students to write about an issue of interest by focusing on a creative and complex question—investigating the question with critical analysis of readings, research and data, and using appropriate research techniques in documentation. Moreover, the course would take seriously its role furthering the process whereby students make the transition to college. As former Director of Expository Writing at Harvard University Nancy Sommers describes this process, “In entering a live debate—a conversation in which more than one view is acceptable and for which there are no easy answers—freshmen see that something is at stake in their work, that their writing is not simply ‘academic’” (137). ITW students would not merely quote from sources and compile a research report. They would be asked to engage with the thoughts and words of others and to construct their point of view from a generative reading of their sources. Students would benefit from sustaining their writing projects across the semester in multiple drafts; and faculty and students would learn together the value of ongoing and constructive feedback during this process.

Yet there was work to do. We first needed to persuade the general education committee to think of a course that would be more than the standard freshman seminar. First, we argued that seminars rarely engage the relationship between thinking and writing. Surely, we all want students to be in classrooms with people preoccupied with the problems and questions that organize their fields of study, we explained. Second, we envisioned writing as the activity through which students recognize those problems and questions, as well as develop their capacity to reason through reading (and rereading) the texts that make up these traditions of thought. It is worth mentioning here that we failed to convince our colleagues that reading was a third key term to feature in the design and pedagogy of the course. As we developed the learning outcomes for the Integrative Studies Program (ISP), in fact, faculty from across the College appeared content with the assumption that reading was a dimension of literacy that had already been acquired by our incoming students in primary and secondary school.

The course we proposed, “Thinking and Writing,” or ITW, would be devoted to the two terms in its title. Our rationale for ITW was that thinking takes shape in the labor of writing—a process most of us experience as trained scholars. Yet most course designs and writing assignments, we argued, simply do not offer students an opportunity to wrestle with genuine intellectual questions and problems. Yes, professors routinely expect critical thinking from students. Yet their assignments do not offer students a sufficient timeline to do the kind of thinking they expect. The notion of a sustained writing project emerged as the organizing principle for the student work in the course. The assumption—and it was proven to be mostly right—would be that even if students did not produce brilliant writing, the challenge of being asked to think for themselves in the first-year course would develop their intellectual abilities in potentially transformative if not lasting ways.

We were fortunate in this effort to have the guidance and support of Nancy Sommers, at the time directing the expository writing program at Harvard, whose longitudinal study of student writers offered empirical evidence for our claims. Nancy’s study suggested that students develop as writers across four years of college—but only insofar as they are given genuine opportunities to think and to write from the first-year course to the senior seminar. We understood writing as a process that calls out half-formulated or unformulated thoughts, gives these thoughts some semblance of form, and extends those thoughts by making new connections. Writing was understood in the course, then, as continuous with reading and thinking. In one sense, the problem of reading would become the focus of writing as students would be asked to sustain their thinking about what they were reading. Reading (and re-reading) through writing would allow students to confront their limited experiences with books, and with experiences, ideas and representations that might differ from their own. The pedagogical challenge was to convince students (and members of the faculty!) that this kind of experience is possible, indeed generative. The curricular challenge was to convince faculty that there are alternatives to our commonplace ways of teaching reading and writing in school.

Three years into this experiment we were offering students ITW sections with biologists, mathematicians, psychologists, historians, as well as scholars working in American, women’s, religious, and environmental studies. One section, for example, taught by a geneticist, asked students to read and write through the cultural implications of the genetic engineering of plants and animals, pre-implantation genetic diagnosis, cloning, and stem cell and reproductive technologies. One of my own sections, “What is Nature?,” traced representations of nature in the Americas, Africa, China, Europe, India and the Arab World. A few years in, we asked faculty about their experience with the sustained writing project––and the commitment to the idea in a first year course. “Teaching this course—and all that teaching this course requires—is as rigorous and relentless an experience as I have ever encountered,” wrote one instructor. “Entering first-year students are unprepared in so many ways for the challenge of a lengthy research-based paper that asks them to take positions about complicated issues.”

Another instructor endorsed the idea of a course based on the process of writing and the idea of organizing a course around the interrelated process of thinking and writing. “Students should continue to write researched papers and sustained writing projects. Multiple drafts and concrete, specific feedback are crucial to this process. Academic argument is the heart of higher education––that’s what scholars do! In her course “Breaking Rules: Women of the Beat Generation,” this faculty member reported, “students are submitting paper proposals; conferencing individually with me; submitting late-stage drafts; and revising drafts for a final paper. How could one do it any other way? By lecture and exam alone? Regurgitation is not learning and it won’t be remembered. I want them to struggle with a focused topic, conducting research in order to learn and contribute to current scholarship.” The instructor concluded, “Students will need research and argument skills in their professional careers. They aren’t going to be required to memorize much data (not in the internet age) but they will need to know where to go to find the data and how to interpret it––that’s what they’ll learn in a sustained writing project.”

But what did our students have to say about ITW? In one narrative assessment of writing experiences at the College sophomore and junior-level students confessed that the opportunity to write about something that mattered to them in ITW was both exciting and terrifying. They talked about their uncertainty completing a sustained writing project. And they described hours of work in the library and their surprise that others had thought deeply about their areas of interest. Yet more importantly, perhaps, was that the students who completed ITW now had a vocabulary to talk about their own thinking and writing as a process. Writing in a substantive intellectual context, they told us again and again, taught them that good thinking takes time. Moreover, they understood that persuasion requires curiosity and careful reading of, in the memorable words of one student, “interesting people with different views on a topic.” Another student was able to say it this way:  “The most effective essays are written by those who truly believe what they are saying, have a well rounded knowledge of the subject, and have put a lot of thought into how to address opposing claims.”

In addition to understanding writing as a process these students experienced the challenge of being asked to think about something. Again and again, they pointed to the unexpected freedom (and responsibility) of being asked to write about something they care about. Describing her experience with the semester-long essay, one student excitedly described developing a “tone of authority combined with credibility, a strong format and use of language.” Another student confessed that he now goes into an argumentative essay believing that he will come out of the process “with a whole new perspective.” And yet another student, writing about encountering adulthood, commented that she was able to “share her experiences with love, death, happiness, and sorrow, and connect it all back to show how these experiences helped me grow and mature.” In doing so, she concluded, “I learned a lot about myself as a person, and was able to explore “my beliefs, my opinions, and my biases.”

In these testimonials we were hearing the kinds of changes that take place as students navigate the difficult transition to college-level writing. The most lasting of these changes involved the experience of being challenged to think on one’s own as well as receiving support to meet those challenges. One student writes, “I put an extreme amount of effort into this essay, and the final product was a huge success.” Another student, however, says something that has stayed with me. “At the end I did not get a really good grade. But I was interested in learning. And I found out a lot about the modern world.”

These student comments left us once again with the question of the opportunities: whether a curriculum that takes thinking and writing to be one of the primary pathways across four years of study was measuring up to the more ambitious goals our students were now setting for themselves. The question was whether we were ready to meet them where they were.

On Thinking Through Writing

In the fall of 2007 I set out to make visible the intellectual work of the cohort teaching in the ITW program. My goal was to embrace and honor the challenges of that work, to document the course, and to archive faculty and student experiences. The Thinking and Writing site I built included a description, core principles and practices, and pages with faculty resources. Still extant, the web log features a fascinating archive of blog posts I composed between 2007 and 2017 that capture a decade of reflections and reports on our evolving project––twenty-three posts in all, from course profiles such as Lorianne DiSabato’s section The Art of Natural History to reflections on ITW such as Something Resembling Authenticity. The web site documents the ebb and flow of reflective practice in medias res and, in doing so, captures the collaborative spirit of inquiry that animated the ITW project from its inception.

In composing this reflection I have been reminded how challenging it really is to sustain the idea of a course among faculty and administrators who too-readily fall back on commonplace ideas of reading, thinking and writing as discrete skills, the so-called opposition between skills and content, and the always-too-general learning outcomes in a common curriculum. It is difficult to hold ideas and keep them in play as disciplines and institutions evolve. Though if this reflection is in part a requiem it is also a reminder that ideas do change and that programs need to evolve and change with the weather––whether handsome or unhandsome. The very idea that a first-year college writing course should be organized around a particular genre, the so-called “academic” or “research” paper, after all, may not be the most efficacious in a first-year college course––especially given the ways that writing has been transformed in digital and multimodal contexts, not to mention the affordances (and risks) of the more recent large language AI tools students now routinely use in the writing process. There is no question that the pedagogical, cultural, and technological conditions for thinking and writing have changed.

The Calderwood Institute and ITW did change how faculty in other areas of study engaged students with writing. The faculty were shaped by thinking and writing too. We have evidence, moreover, that tenure-track faculty who taught ITW engaged their colleagues with the use of writing as learning in their disciplines. But building and sustaining a culture of writing in higher education is ongoing and challenging work I have been thinking since I accepted an invitation to be an external evaluator for the English program in the Department of Global Humanities at Norwich College in Northfield, Vermont. Their two-semester writing sequence––EN 110 Writing and Inquiry in Public Contexts and EN 111 Writing and Inquiry in Academic Contexts––reminded me what we did not accomplish during the more than two decades I served as a full-time member of the faculty at Keene State: a developmental sequence of writing courses in the general education program and/or in the disciplines. Like many colleges and universities, of course, Norwich faces the familiar challenge of engaging more faculty in what should be common work. It reminded me of the many years at Keene State when the monthly ITW dinner meetings, attended by mostly committed contingent faculty, was where the most exciting conversations about student learning were taking place. With these energies circulating on the margins, I guess it is not surprising that the tenure-track faculty teaching model we envisioned for ITW never happened, or that we failed to implement a developmental sequence of meaningful writing experiences in the curriculum.

In my current role as faculty emeritus, my plans include teaching ITW—or, whatever the faculty will end up naming the course––if they will have me. But I need to confess that this coming fall, when I step into another classroom of first-year students, I will undoubtedly be carrying with me the questions and assumptions of the ITW project. As I compose writing prompts, I will think carefully about the level of complexity of the assignment and whether or not it invites my students into the world of ideas / concepts / theories of the course I will be teaching, “Poetry as a Way of Knowing.” I will ask my students to talk with me about the real purpose of my writing prompts to find out whether they are clear to them, and just as important to me. “What do you really, really want them to get from the experience of putting word after word on paper, in other words, what is my hidden agenda, my real agenda,” I will hear my friend Phyllis asking me. I will keep the level of intellectual challenge as high as possible because, as Phyllis’ voice will remind me, “that’s the only way to reinforce what you really, really want.” And I will work with the students to reach a shared understanding of what it is I am asking of them––and why.

Most of these principles are predicated on “meaningful writing,” the felicitous term Anne Ellen Geller, Michele Eodice, and Neal Lerner use in making their case for metacognitive pedagogical reflection on our assignments. I want to be honest with myself whether or not the work is something worth doing; and I want to challenge my conviction that the language of my assignments is somehow transparent to my students. I am pretty sure, too, other lessons from ITW will be a menace to any and all of my pedagogical complacencies. Does my assignment really challenge students—beyond asking them to demonstrate an understanding of a subject or an idea? How can writing for multiple audiences help students “transcend the assignment” and claim ownership of their ideas? How am I reading for, commenting on, and responding to student writing? How will I incorporate a holding environment into the writing process? That is, as my students struggle, how will I show up? How will I create the tension in learning to help them through the writing process without diminishing the purpose or level of complexity? (Come to think of it, I may even go back and fortify myself by rereading two essays I routinely shared with faculty working with student writers by Gordon Harvey: “Asking For It: Imagining the Role of Student Writing” (1997) and “Repetitive Strain: The Injuries of Responding to Student Writing” (2003). Mostly, though, I will be thinking about how to teach beyond the ending: that is, by asking myself how the way I design and teach my course might change not so much the writing of a student but the student as a thinker and writer.

What is it that we know? What is it that we need to know? One thing we know is that snapshot assessments of artifacts seeking to assess student writing divert our attention from the changes taking place in a writer as they move through and beyond the first year. As Nancy Sommers and Laura Saltz write in the essay I cited earlier, The Novice as Expert: Writing the Freshman Year, a longitudinal perspective on student writers suggests that changes in attitude about academic work and the ability to see a greater purpose in writing beyond completing an assignment are crucial to continued development across the four years of an undergraduate education. “The story of the freshman year is not one of dramatic changes on paper,” they remind us, “it is the story of changes within the writers themselves” (144). The promise of this kind of development was always central to ITW––an uncommon pedagogical collaborative that for better and worse has come to an end.

Note

I began writing this reflection on the ITW project as Keene State College moved toward approving a new General Education curriculum that includes, not incidentally, a new first-year writing course. This essay is written in memory of my dear friend, the late Phyllis Benay, who is most responsible for the success and integrity of the ITW project. Though without the creative thinking and critical acumen of Kirsti Sandy, the conception and implementation of ITW might not have ever come to be. Others helped along way as well, notably Jan Youga, Nona Fienberg, Kate Tirabbassi, and Celia Rabinowitz.

Though it was the intelligence, commitment, and energy of tenure-track and contingent faculty who sustained the ITW project. They include Anne-Marie Mallon, Jack Hitchner, Daryl LeDuc, Steve Kessler, Tracy Mendham, Jack Bouley, Tracy Botting, George Russell, Beth Stickney, Heather Gigliello, Vesta Hornbeck, Laurie Stulbarg, and Alice Foley (English); Ali Lichtensein (English and Women’s Studies); Richard Foley (Technology, Design & Safety); Mike Wakefield and Ellen Moynihan (English and Communications); Helen Frink (Modern Languages); Robert Rubin, Nick Germana, Graham Warder, and Greg Knouff (History); Allyson Mount (Philosophy); Susan Whitemore and Kristen Porter-Utley (Biology); PeggyRae Johnson (Theater and Dance); Tatiana Schreiber (Environmental Studies), Becky Dunn (Health Science); Rosemary Gianno (Anthropology), Sara Hottinger (Philosophy and Women’s Studies); Deborah White Stanley (Film) and David Gonthier (Film and English); Mark Timney (Journalism); Wanda Swiger (Physical Education); Jennifer Ditkoff, Irene McGarrity, and Elizabeth Dolinger (Mason Library); and Dottie Bauer, Len Fleisher, Tanya Sturtz, and Daryl Hucks (Education), and Molly Parsons (The Center for Writing). 

Photo credit: Mark C. Long

A Nice Place to Visit

“Virtual space is a place to explore identity.”

—Sherry Turkle, Reclaiming Conversation: The Power of Talk in a Digital Age (2018)

The other day my friend Marie visited this blog, The Far Field, and then sent me an email. “You always make the reader feel welcome,” she wrote, “and on your site it’s as if the world had slowed down. It’s a nice place to visit.”

I’m interested in this description of the practice of writing on a web log as a way of slowing down–of thinking aloud, learning through exploration, making connections, and organizing the activity of the mind at work. This creative discipline of forming sentences and paragraphs, with perhaps the incorporation of other media, brings me back to one of my digital inspirations, the Hoarded Ordinaries project. “Writers, like children, are not dissuaded by the uselessness of hoarded ordinaries,” Lorrianne observes”; instead, we cultivate a collector’s sense, trying to capture mundane moments on a string of words.” After all, reading and thinking, observing and writing, are deliberate activities. They slow us down.

At the same time, Marie’s comment has me thinking about the writing I do with my students—short-form essays on my course blogs  written to create time and space to slow the fast-paced obligations and responsibilities of my professional life. In thinking and writing it is as if time indeed slows, as if eddies form in the flow, capturing  an ordinary, or maybe extraordinary, happening in teaching and learning. Might a course blog, too, be a nice place to visit?

Increasingly our minds are less focused—or so we tell ourselves. We are distracted, we say, by technology and the hyper-pace of modern life. Our attention to the things happening outside of our heads leaves us less attentive to the ways that attention shapes us. More importantly, our attention is increasingly appropriated in public and, more and more, in digital space. As Mathew B. Crawford writes in a fabulously interesting book, The World Beyond Your Head: On Becoming an Individual in an Age of Distraction, “our predicament is that we engage less than we once did in everyday activities that structure our attention” (23). Crawford is interested in skilled practices that establish what he calls “ecologies of attention.” His larger claim is that our environment constitutes the self and that attention to the world beyond our heads is at the center of this formative process.

What I find most useful in this line of thinking is a potentially more capacious and generous approach to our increasingly mediated lives. Blaming technology for appropriating our attention simplifies what is a far more interesting and enduring idea that the self is autonomous and striving to free itself by controlling the external world. Crawford calls this “autonomy talk,” with roots in Enlightenment epistemology and moral theory

which did important polemical work in their day against various forms of coercion. Times have changed. The philosophical project of this book is to reclaim the real, as against representations. That is why the central term of approbation in these pages is not ‘freedom’ but ‘agency.’ For it is when we are engaged in a skilled practice that the world shows up for us as having a reality of its own, independent of the self. . . . (27)

One of Crawford’s interests is how when someone is engaged in a skilled practice the world shows up, as it were. Skilled practices are deliberate, and even when fast-moving, or dynamic, depend upon a kind of slowness. The ways we frame our relationship to the world in terms of freedom and constraint are as persistent as they are debilitating.

When we write, too, we are attending to the world. But if we think with the fiction of writing as a solitary practice or private act, we are thinking again with the idea of the self is autonomous and striving to free itself by controlling the external world. Sitting and writing in solitude we obscure writing as an embodied practice at once socially and historically situated.

Before Marie wrote to me I had a vague idea that the writing I was doing on my course blogs was what some people call a “flipped” classroom. But the flipped strategy flops as a description of what is actually going on when I write with my students about the literary and cultural materials we are studying together. For the challenge is to understand the social and rhetorical activity of writing through asking students, as well as myself, to to think with these materials on the open web.

If writing is a way of learning, and we are asking our students to write in the open, then we should be writing to learn about the practice of teaching, and we should be doing so in the open as well. If in fact virtual space is a place to explore identity, then we should join our students in this exploration.

Writing on the open web begins with the very real possibility that the words you are putting together might actually be read. When we write we are always writing for particular purposes (even though we may not always be clear what those purposes are) and in shaping words we are putting together for imagined or unanticipated audiences; and we are always writing with the words and ideas of others, using existing strategies and genres and tools. In addition to understanding writing as a collaborative activity there is important work in understanding what writing does—or can do. The idea that writing is a way of one’s sharing understanding of one thing or another underscores writing as a constitutive activity. Writing is poetic in the fundamental sense that when we write we are building and constructing ideas through the act of thinking. And because writing is a cultural activity that mediates the process of thinking, writing might be understood as a way of claiming the contents of one’s mind.

Thinking aloud about ideas and materials with students—for me most often the words of a poem, a sentence or paragraph of student writing, a surprising turn in class, or a reflection following a class meeting—has become a practice of thinking about what I am doing, and why, in medias res. Might a teaching philosophy emerge in the network of relations of each unique group of students rather than a statement written antequam aliquid incipit? Might methods of teaching be predicated less on mastery and expertise and more on discovery? Might we resist habit and routine by implicating ourselves more fully in the activity of teaching as learning through writing with our students about the subject we profess?

In so doing, teachers build networks of connections beyond the timelines generated by algorithms that filter and present virtual reality in a ready-made stream. Teachers model for students learning beyond the closed design of learning management systems. And teachers guide their students in understanding their complicity in the accelerated streams of social media platforms designed to surveil and to sell. If we are going to argue for a poetics of digital identity, fluency, and citizenship as necessary elements of twenty-first century learning then teachers should be building their own identities, fluencies, and citizenship.

What are English Majors Saying about Thinking and Writing?

In the first part of our two-course introductory sequence to the English major I ask students to write an essay about their experiences with academic writing. Their five-page essays allow me to see how students think about writing; and their thinking provides the occasion for an extended discussion about motivations for doing intellectual work in English. Their essays also make visible some impressions of our new first-year course, Thinking and Writing (ITW).

Not surprisingly, thirty-four of the forty essays on academic writing I’ve read this year mention the ITW course. The students who mention ITW confess that the opportunity to write about something that mattered to them is both exciting and terrifying. They express uncertainty about completing a 15-20 page essay. They describe hours of work in the library and their surprise that in fact others have thought about their areas of interest. And they point out how skeptical they are that the area they are writing about is interesting enough for a semester-long project.

If anything, we can count on students coming out of ITW with a vocabulary to talk about thinking and writing as a process. (More so than the students who completed our essay writing course.) Writing in a substantive intellectual context, they tell me, has taught them that good thinking takes time. Moreover, they understand that persuasion requires curiosity and careful reading of, in the memorable words of one student, “interesting people with different views on a topic.” Another student is able to say it this way:  “The most effective essays are written by those who truly believe what they are saying, have a well rounded knowledge of the subject, and have put a lot of thought into how to address opposing claims.”

In addition to understanding writing as a process these students have experienced the challenge of being asked to think about something. Again and again, they point to the unexpected freedom of being asked to write about something they care about. Describing her experience with the semester-long essay, one student excitedly describes developing a “tone of authority combined with credibility, a strong format and use of language.” Another student confesses that he now goes into an argumentative essay believing that he will come out of the process “with a whole new perspective.” And yet another student, writing about encountering adulthood, comments that she was able to “share her experiences with love, death, happiness, and sorrow, and connect it all back to show how these experiences helped me grow and mature.” And in doing so, she concludes, “I learned a lot about myself as a person, and was able to explore “my beliefs, my opinions, and my biases.”

In listening to these testimonials we begin to hear the kinds of changes that take place as students navigate the difficult transition to college-level writing. These changes-as longitudinal studies of student writers confirm time after time-do not necessarily appear on the page. Rather the changes take place in the writer. The most lasting of these changes, it follows, are those that involve the experience of being challenged to think on one’s own as well as receiving support to meet those challenges. One student writes, “I put an extreme amount of effort into this essay, and the final product was a huge success.” Another student, however, says something that has stayed with me. “At the end I did not get a really good grade. But I was interested in learning. And I found out a lot about the modern world.”

Such comments may speak to the dedication of those who of us teach the thinking and writing course. But these  student, more importantly, make visible the kinds of changes students experience in their first college-level writing course. One question is whether a curriculum that takes thinking and writing to be one of the primary pathways across the four years is a curriculum will measure up to the more ambitious goals our students may now be setting for themselves. The question is whether we are ready to meet them where they are.